Exercise 1: From electron configuration to polarity
Consider two molecules of sulfur and xenon, and , whose formulas look so alike that they are often assumed to have the same shape. Atomic numbers: S 16, Xe 54, F 9.
- a) Give the electron configuration of sulfur and deduce its number of valence electrons. Why can sulfur exceed the octet when oxygen, just above it in the periodic table, cannot?
- b) Count the valence electrons of , draw its Lewis structure, then give its electron-domain arrangement, its molecular geometry and the hybridization of sulfur.
- c) Repeat the same analysis for .
- d) Both molecules have lone pairs on the central atom. Yet one is polar and the other is not. Explain.
- e) Rank , and by increasing boiling point, justifying your answer with intermolecular forces.
Show the solution
Answers
- a) Sulfur , 6 valence electrons; the orbitals allow the expanded octet
- b) 34 electrons, one lone pair, 5 domains, , seesaw geometry
- c) 36 electrons, two lone pairs, 6 domains, , square planar geometry
- d) nonpolar by symmetry, polar: only the geometry decides
- e) , that is , and °C: dispersion wins
Sulfur: , that is 6 valence electrons in the shell. Sulfur can exceed the octet because its valence shell contains vacant orbitals, energetically accessible, which allow up to 12 electrons around it. Oxygen is in period 2: its valence shell has only the and orbitals, at most four boxes, so eight electrons and not one more. The octet is not an arbitrary rule, it is a count of the available boxes.
: valence electrons, that is 17 pairs. Four S-F bonds use up 4 pairs, each fluorine keeps 3, that is 12, and 1 LONE pair is left on sulfur. Sulfur therefore carries 5 domains: TRIGONAL BIPYRAMIDAL arrangement, hybridization. The lone pair sits in an equatorial position, where it is least crowded, and the molecular geometry is SEESAW.
: electrons, that is 18 pairs. Four bonds, 12 pairs on the fluorines, which leaves 2 lone pairs on xenon, so 6 domains: OCTAHEDRAL arrangement, hybridization. The two lone pairs take opposite positions, 180° apart, to minimize their repulsion, and the four fluorines end up in one plane: the geometry is SQUARE PLANAR.
Polarity does not depend on the presence of lone pairs but on the SYMMETRY of the whole. In square planar , the four Xe-F bond dipoles cancel in pairs and the two opposite lone pairs cancel as well: the molecule is NONPOLAR despite four very polar bonds. In seesaw the arrangement is asymmetric: neither the bonds nor the lone pair find an opposite partner, the dipoles add up partially and the molecule is POLAR. Two molecules with lone pairs, two opposite answers: only the geometry decides.
is tetrahedral and therefore nonpolar, is nonpolar too, is polar. Between the two nonpolar molecules only dispersion forces act, and they grow with molar mass and number of electrons: (207 g/mol) far outweighs (88 g/mol). (108 g/mol) adds dipole-dipole interactions to its dispersion. The increasing order is therefore , then , then , and the observed values are indeed °C, °C and °C. Note that the heaviest molecule beats the polar one: dispersion, often presented as the weakest force, becomes dominant as soon as the electron cloud is large.
Tick the exercises you have done or want to review: a free account, no password, keeps your ticks and your right answers from one visit to the next, tells you which chapter to tackle next and lets you ask for the exercise you are missing. Create your space, an email is enough.