Chemistry of Solutions 202-SN2-RE • CEGEP, Montreal
Revision sheet: acids and bases (202-SN2-RE)
This whole chapter follows from two constants, Kw and Ka, and a single question asked before every calculation: what is in the solution at this precise moment? An acid alone, a mixture of an acid and its conjugate base, a conjugate base alone, or a strong base in excess: four situations, four distinct methods.
This sheet gives the four methods in the order in which they appear along a titration, the link between a conjugate pair and the acidic or basic character of a salt, and the list of mistakes on buffers that come back from one exam to the next. It is written for CEGEP students in Chemistry of Solutions, 202-SN2-RE (formerly 202-NYB).
Mark this sheet as read or add it to your favourites: a free account, no password, keeps your read sheets and favourites from one visit to the next, tells you which chapter to tackle next and lets you ask for the method or exercise you are missing. Create your space, an email is enough.
The thread of the chapter
Before any calculation, decide which REGION you are in: acid alone, buffer mixture, equivalence point, excess base. Each region has its own method, and applying the method of one region in another is the costliest mistake of the chapter.
•Conjugate pair: Ka×Kb=Kw, so pKa+pKb=14. The stronger an acid, the weaker its conjugate base.
•An acid-base reaction is favoured in the direction that goes from the STRONGER acid to the weaker acid.
The three scales are read together: one pH unit is a factor of 10 on [H3O+], and the pOH reads backwards, since pH+pOH=14.
The scale is logarithmic: one pH unit represents a factor of 10 on the concentration. A pH given to two decimal places therefore corresponds to two significant figures on the concentration, no more.
The four regions of a titration
•BEFORE any addition: weak acid alone, ICE table with Ka.
•BETWEEN the start and the equivalence point: a mixture of acid and conjugate base, so a BUFFER. pH=pKa+log[acid][base].
•At the HALF-EQUIVALENCE point: the two forms are in equal amounts, so pH=pKa exactly. It is the easiest point on the graph.
•At the EQUIVALENCE point: only the conjugate base remains, so the pH is BASIC, never 7. Apply Kb=KaKw to the diluted concentration.
•AFTER the equivalence point: strong base in excess; ignore everything else and calculate [OH−] from the amount in excess over the total volume.
The jump does NOT pass through 7: the equivalence point sits at 8.7, because only the conjugate base remains at that stage. The half-equivalence point, for its part, gives the pKa directly by simple reading.
The equivalence pH is exactly 7 only for a strong acid titrated with a strong base. With a weak acid it is above 7, with a weak base it is below 7.
Buffers and salts
•A buffer is a mixture of a weak acid AND its conjugate base, in comparable amounts. It absorbs small additions of acid or base.
•pH=pKa+log[acid][base]: the BASE goes in the numerator. The ratio can be written in moles, since the volume cancels.
•A buffer is most effective when pH=pKa, that is, when the two forms are in equal amounts. So choose the acid whose pKa is closest to the target pH.
•Diluting a buffer hardly changes its pH: the ratio of the two forms is preserved.
•Hydrolysis of salts: the cation of a strong base and the anion of a strong acid give a NEUTRAL salt; the anion of a weak acid makes it BASIC; the cation of a weak base makes it ACIDIC.
Only the ion that comes from a WEAK species reacts with water: NH4+ makes the solution acidic, acetate makes it basic, and NaCl, made of two spectator ions, stays at 7.
Buffer capacity is finite: as soon as the addition exceeds the amount of one of the two forms, the buffer breaks down and the pH drops abruptly. This is exactly what the jump of a titration shows.
The mistakes that cost marks
These are the errors I correct most often in session. Each one costs marks on a paper, even when the reasoning behind it is right.
1.Treating a weak acid as a strong acid
the whole question, 6 points
What not to write
“The acetic acid solution is 0.100 mol/L, so [H3O+]=0.100 and pH=1.00.”
What to write
“Acetic acid is WEAK: 0.100−xx2=1.8×10−5 gives x=1.33×10−3 and pH=2.87.”
The same acetic acid: believing it strong gives 1.00, treating it with Ka gives 2.87. Nearly two units apart, a factor of 75 on [H3O+].
Why: Only the six usual strong acids dissociate completely. A weak acid at 0.100 mol/L is only 1.3% ionized, which changes the pH by almost two units.
2.Setting the equivalence pH of a weak-acid titration at seven
the whole question, 5 points, and the choice of indicator missed
What not to write
“At the equivalence point, all the acid is neutralized, so pH=7.00.”
What to write
“Only the ACETATE ION remains, a weak conjugate base: its hydrolysis gives pH=8.72. The pH equals 7 only between a strong acid and a strong base.”
The equivalence pH is that of the PRODUCT formed: 7 between two strong species only, above 7 with a weak acid, below 7 with a weak base.
Why: Neutralizing does not mean making neutral: it means consuming the acid. What remains is a base, and its hydrolysis imposes a pH above 7.
3.Inverting the ratio in the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation
3 points, and a pH that is the mirror image of the right one about the pKa
What not to write
“pH=pKa+log[base][acid].”
What to write
“The BASE goes in the numerator: pH=pKa+log[acid][base]. The more base there is, the higher the pH, which is the only consistent reading.”
Adding base must make the pH RISE: only the green curve does. The inverted ratio gives a pH that is the mirror image of the right one about the pKa.
Why: The error is invisible when the two forms are in equal amounts, since the logarithm is then zero. It shows up as soon as the ratio moves away from 1, and the check is immediate: adding base must raise the pH.
4.Using the buffer formula outside the buffer region
the whole question, 5 points
What not to write
“After the equivalence point, I still have acetate and a little acid, so I apply Henderson-Hasselbalch.”
What to write
“After the equivalence point there is no weak acid left at all: there is STRONG base in excess, and [OH−] is calculated from the amount in excess divided by the TOTAL volume.”
In the green band, Henderson-Hasselbalch follows the true curve; near the equivalence point it shoots off to infinity, and after it the formula is meaningless: the strong base alone decides.
Why: Henderson-Hasselbalch assumes that both forms of the pair coexist in comparable amounts. A single drop of strong base in excess imposes its own pH and makes the formula inapplicable.
5.Adding the two ionizations of a polyprotic acid
3 points
What not to write
“Phosphoric acid has three ionizations, so [H3O+] is three times what the first gives.”
What to write
“Only the FIRST counts: Ka1=7.1×10−3 against Ka2=6.3×10−8, a hundred thousand times smaller. The second is negligible next to the first.”
The three constants of phosphoric acid are separated by about five pKa units, so by a factor of a hundred thousand. Next to the first, the other two weigh nothing.
Why: Pulling a second proton off a species that is already negatively charged costs much more: successive constants drop by about five orders of magnitude at each step.
6.Believing that every salt gives a neutral solution
4 points
What not to write
“Sodium acetate comes from the neutralization of an acid by a base, so its solution is neutral.”
What to write
“The acetate ion is the conjugate base of a WEAK acid: it hydrolyzes and makes the solution BASIC. Only salts of a strong acid and a strong base are neutral.”
Why: The conjugate base of a strong acid, such as the chloride ion, is so weak that it does not react. That of a weak acid, by contrast, is a measurable base, and its Kb equals KaKw.
7.Believing that diluting a buffer changes its pH
3 points on the reasoning question
What not to write
“I dilute the buffer ten times, so its pH goes up by one unit.”
What to write
“The ratio [acid][base] is UNCHANGED by dilution, so the pH stays practically the same. It is its CAPACITY that decreases, not its pH.”
The two buffers start at the SAME pH, 4.74: dilution changed nothing. But 100 mL of the diluted buffer gives way after only 1 mmol of acid, ten times sooner than the original.
Why: Both concentrations are divided by the same factor, and only their ratio enters the formula. A diluted buffer, however, is broken down by an addition ten times smaller.
8.Adding Ka and Kb instead of multiplying them
3 points
What not to write
“Ka+Kb=Kw, so Kb=1.0×10−14−1.8×10−5, which is negative.”
What to write
“Ka×Kb=Kw, so Kb=1.8×10−51.0×10−14=5.6×10−10. It is the pK values that ADD: pKa+pKb=14.”
Why: The relation comes from the sum of the two equilibria, and adding equations MULTIPLIES their constants. The negative result obtained by adding is, moreover, impossible for a constant.
9.Forgetting the dilution caused by the added volume in a titration
2 points, and a shifted equivalence pH
What not to write
“At the equivalence point, the acetate concentration is 0.100 mol/L, like the starting acid.”
What to write
“The volume has DOUBLED, since 25.0 mL was added to 25.0 mL: the acetate concentration is 0.0500 mol/L.”
The 2.50 mmol of acetate are in 50.0 mL at the equivalence point, not in 25.0 mL: the concentration is halved.
Why: All concentrations in a titration are calculated on the TOTAL volume, burette included. It is one of the few quantities that the buffer lets you forget, since the volume cancels there.
10.Calculating a pH without checking that it is on the right side of seven
3 points, but the error can be spotted in a second
What not to write
“The ammonia solution has a pH of 2.9.”
What to write
“Ammonia is a BASE: its pH must exceed 7. Calculate [OH−], then pOH, then pH=14−pOH=11.1.”
A base gives a pH above 7: 2.9 is the pOH of the ammonia, and it is 14−2.9=11.1 that must be written.
Why: A weak base is handled with Kb and first gives a pOH. Forgetting the last subtraction gives an acidic pH for a base, which plain common sense rejects.
Which method to choose
Which region of the titration are we in
Compare the amount of base added with the starting amount of acid
The count in MOLES designates the region: acid alone, acid and conjugate base together, conjugate base alone, then strong base in excess. Each column has its own formula.
If no base added → weak acid alone: ICE table with Ka
Example: 0.100 mol/L acetic acid gives pH=2.87
If base added in an amount LESS than the acid → buffer: pH=pKa+lognacidnbase, in moles, the volume cancelling
Example: at the half-equivalence point, pH=pKa exactly
If base added EXACTLY equal to the acid → equivalence point: only the conjugate base remains, apply Kb=KaKw to the TOTAL volume
Example: pH=8.72 for acetate at 0.0500 mol/L
If base added in EXCESS → strong base alone: [OH−]=Vtotalnexcess, everything else is negligible
Example: 1.0 mL of excess already gives pH≈11.3 (0.100 mol/L base, 25.0 mL sample)
If we start from a SALT and not from an acid → identify which of the two ions hydrolyzes, then apply Ka or Kb to that ion
the ion coming from the STRONG species is a spectator and never takes part
The first line of the answer must always be a count in MOLES, not in concentrations: it decides the region, and it stays valid whatever the volume added.
Which formula for which type of solution
The exact nature of the dissolved species
If strong acid → [H3O+]=C0 and pH=−logC0, with no table
If weak acid → Ka, ICE table, approximation tested at 5%
Example: x=KaC0 if the test passes
If weak base, including the conjugate base of a weak acid → Kb=KaKw, ICE table, then pOH then pH
Example: acetate, ammonia, carbonate ion
If mixture of a weak acid AND its conjugate base → Henderson-Hasselbalch, with the BASE in the numerator
the ratio can be written in moles, which avoids calculating the total volume
An ion like chloride or sodium never does anything: it comes from a strong species, so its conjugate is too weak to react. Spotting it right away often simplifies the question by half.
How the answer is expected to be written
A marker ticks steps. Here they are in order, with the concluding sentence expected word for word.
Preparing a buffer and calculating its pH after an addition
When to use it: The question asks you to make up a buffer at a given pH, or to calculate the effect of adding acid or base to an existing buffer.
1Calculate pKa=−logKa and compare it with the target pH: their difference gives the logarithm of the ratio directly.
2Deduce nacidnbase=10pH−pKa, then the two amounts from the imposed total amount.
3When adding a strong acid, count in MOLES: the added acid converts base into acid, mole for mole. An added base does the opposite.
4Recalculate the pH with the new amounts, always by Henderson-Hasselbalch.
5Compare the pH change obtained with what pure water would have undergone, and conclude on the effectiveness of the buffer.
Concluding sentence
“Adding 0.0100 mol of hydrochloric acid converts as much acetate into acetic acid: the amounts become 0.0543 and 0.0457 mol, hence pH=4.74+log0.04570.0543=4.82, a drop of only 0.18 unit.”
The trap: Reasoning in concentrations rather than in moles when adding. If the volume changes, the ratio stays correct in moles but all the concentrations would have to be recalculated: better to spare yourself that.
Marking: Typically 1 point for the pKa, 2 for the ratio and the amounts, 2 for the count after the addition, 2 for the new pH, 1 for the comparison with pure water.
Calculating the pH at the equivalence point of a weak-acid titration
When to use it: The question asks for the pH at the equivalence point, or for the choice of a colour indicator.
1Calculate the amount of conjugate base formed: it equals the starting amount of acid.
2Calculate the TOTAL VOLUME, that of the sample plus that added, and deduce the concentration of the conjugate base.
3Calculate Kb=KaKw and write the ICE table for the hydrolysis.
4Obtain [OH−], then pOH, then pH=14−pOH, and check that the result exceeds 7.
5Choose an indicator whose transition range brackets this pH, not the one for a strong-strong titration.
Concluding sentence
“At the equivalence point, 0.00250 mol of acetate is in 50.0 mL, that is 0.0500 mol/L; with Kb=5.6×10−10, we obtain [OH−]=5.3×10−6 mol/L, so pOH=5.28 and pH=8.72.”
The trap: Using the initial concentration of the acid instead of the diluted concentration. The volume has doubled if the two solutions have the same concentration, which shifts the equivalence pH by more than a tenth of a unit.
Check before you hand in
Five minutes of checking recover more marks than one more problem started in a hurry.
The pH on the right side of seven
An acid must give a pH below 7, a base a pH above. It is the fastest check and it catches the forgotten subtraction 14−pOH.
A pH of 2.9 reported for ammonia: it is the pOH that was given.
The pH of a buffer close to its pKa
A usable buffer has a pH within one unit of its pKa. A gap of three units signals an error in the ratio or a poorly chosen pair.
An acetate buffer reported at pH=8.5 when its pKa is 4.74: it is no longer a buffer.
The five percent test on the ionization
After the approximation, check that the percent ionization stays below 5%. Otherwise, redo it with the full quadratic equation.
A weak acid diluted to 10−4 mol/L is ionized by more than 30%: the approximation is invalid.
The total volume in every titration concentration
Go back over each concentration calculated and check that it is divided by the TOTAL volume, burette included.
A concentration at the equivalence point equal to the starting one: the added volume was forgotten.
The direction of change after an addition
Adding an acid must always make the pH FALL, adding a base must make it rise, even in a buffer.
A pH that rises after adding hydrochloric acid: the Henderson ratio was inverted.
The typical problem, taken apart
Preparing an acetate buffer, then pushing it to the breaking point
We want to prepare 500 mL of a buffer solution at pH 5.00 from acetic acid and sodium acetate, the total concentration of the two forms being 0.200 mol/L. Given: Ka=1.8×10−5.
Determine the amounts of each form, then the pH after adding 0.0100 mol of hydrochloric acid. Compare with the same addition to 500 mL of pure water. Finally, determine the amount of hydrochloric acid that would completely break the buffer.
The same addition of 0.0100 mol of hydrochloric acid, in the buffer and in pure water: this is the comparison the example works out.
Step 1
pKa=−log(1.8×10−5)=4.74. The target pH being 5.00, we have lognacidnbase=5.00−4.74=0.26, so nacidnbase=100.26=1.80.
Why
The gap between the target pH and the pKa gives the logarithm of the ratio directly: that is the whole point of the logarithmic form of Henderson-Hasselbalch.
Step 2
Total amount: 0.200×0.500=0.100 mol. With the ratio 1.80: nbase=0.100×2.801.80=0.0643 mol and nacid=0.0357 mol.
Why
The total amount is split according to the ratio, which avoids solving a system. The two must add back up to 0.100 mol, an immediate check.
Step 3
Check: pH=4.74+log0.03570.0643=4.74+0.26=5.00, as specified.
Why
Recalculating the pH from the amounts found validates the ratio and the split at once, before moving on to the part that really matters.
Step 4
Addition of 0.0100 mol of hydrochloric acid: it converts as much acetate into acetic acid. nbase=0.0643−0.0100=0.0543 mol and nacid=0.0357+0.0100=0.0457 mol.
Why
The count is done in MOLES, and the strong acid reacts completely: there is no equilibrium to solve at this step, only bookkeeping.
Step 5
New pH: 4.74+log0.04570.0543=4.74+0.075=4.82. The drop is only 0.18 unit.
Why
The volume appears nowhere, since it cancels in the ratio: this is what makes the buffer calculation so quick, and also why dilution does not change its pH.
Step 6
In 500 mL of pure water: [H3O+]=0.5000.0100=0.0200 mol/L, so pH=1.70. The drop is 5.3 units from 7.
Why
The comparison quantifies the effect of the buffer: thirty times less change, which is a factor of more than a hundred thousand on the hydronium ion concentration.
Step 7
Breaking point: the buffer holds as long as acetate remains, that is, up to 0.0643 mol of hydrochloric acid. With 0.0700 mol, the excess is 0.0057 mol, so [H3O+]=0.0114 mol/L and pH=1.94.
Why
Buffer capacity is finite and can be calculated: it is the smaller of the two amounts of the pair. Once it is exceeded, we go back to the calculation for a strong acid in excess.
Step 8
Plausibility check: the breaking-point pH, 1.94, is indeed close to that of acidified pure water, 1.70, which confirms that the buffer no longer plays any role.
Why
The result must rejoin the behaviour of pure water once the capacity is used up. If it stayed far from it, the breaking-point amount would have been miscalculated.
The conclusion, written out
“The buffer is prepared with 0.0643 mol of acetate and 0.0357 mol of acetic acid. Adding 0.0100 mol of hydrochloric acid lowers its pH only from 5.00 to 4.82, against a fall from 7 to 1.70 in pure water; it would take 0.0643 mol to exhaust it completely.”
The classic mistake on this problem: Inverting the ratio and writing lognbasenacid. This gives 4.49 instead of 5.00, a value that is the mirror image of the right result about the pKa: it is this symmetry that makes the error invisible without the direction check.
Learn by heart
•pH+pOH=14 at 25 °C, and Ka×Kb=Kw, so pKa+pKb=14.
•pH=pKa+log[acid][base]: the BASE goes in the numerator.
•Half-equivalence point: pH=pKa exactly. Equivalence point of a weak acid: pH>7.
•After the equivalence point, ignore the pair: it is the strong base in excess that sets the pH.
•Diluting a buffer does not change its pH, only its CAPACITY.
•Polyprotic acid: only the FIRST ionization counts, the following ones are a hundred thousand times weaker.
•A salt is neutral only if both ions come from STRONG species; otherwise it hydrolyzes.
Frequently asked questions
Why is the pH at the equivalence point of a weak acid not seven?
Because at the equivalence point all the acid has been turned into its conjugate base, which is a weak base. This base hydrolyzes and releases hydroxide ions, which makes the solution basic. The equivalence pH is seven only when a strong acid is titrated with a strong base, because the ions left over are then inert.
How do I choose the right pair to prepare a buffer?
Choose the weak acid whose pKa is closest to the desired pH, ideally within one unit. The buffer is at its best when the pH equals the pKa, because the two forms are then present in equal amounts and it can absorb as much acid as base. Beyond one unit of difference, the capacity collapses on one side.
Does the pH of a buffer change when it is diluted?
Practically not. The Henderson equation involves only the ratio of the two forms, and dilution divides both by the same factor. What decreases is the capacity: a buffer diluted ten times is broken down by an addition ten times smaller, even though its starting pH is identical.
Why do we count only the first ionization of a polyprotic acid?
Because the successive constants drop by about five orders of magnitude at each step. Pulling a second proton off a species that is already negatively charged is much harder. The contribution of the second ionization to the hydronium ions is therefore negligible next to that of the first, unless the question explicitly asks about the minor species.
Is a salt solution always neutral?
No. It is neutral only if both of its ions come from strong species, like sodium chloride. If the anion is the conjugate base of a weak acid, it hydrolyzes and the solution becomes basic. If the cation is the conjugate acid of a weak base, the solution becomes acidic. Ammonium chloride, for example, gives an acidic solution.
How do I know which method to use during a titration?
Compare, in moles, the base added with the starting acid. Before any addition, it is a weak acid alone. Between the start and the equivalence point, it is a buffer. At the exact equivalence point, it is the conjugate base alone. After that, it is the strong base in excess that sets everything. Four regions, four methods, and the count in moles tells them apart.
Practise it
Corrected exercises: Acids and bases, 202-SN2-RE
A method is proved on a paper, not on a sheet. The set for the same chapter takes each of these traps into a problem, with the solution written out step by step.
Something missing from this sheet?A method, a trap, an exercise to practise it, a mistake you spotted: tell me, I read every request.
Sending goes through your free space: that is how I can answer you and tell you when the exercise is added. An email is enough, no password. Create your space.
Rather not create an account? Write to me directly.
Get in touch for a first session. On acids and bases, we first work on identifying the region: the calculation is never the problem, the choice of method always is.