Revision sheet: rotation of rigid bodies (203-SN1-RE)
Rotation takes all the mechanics you have already seen and changes every symbol: x becomes θ, m becomes I, F becomes τ. The equations are therefore known in advance. The difficulty lies elsewhere: I depends on the chosen axis, and a single object has as many moments of inertia as there are possible axes.
This sheet gathers the mistakes specific to this chapter: the axis that is not named, the lever arm confused with the distance, the pulley wrongly idealized, and the two quantities, energy and angular momentum, of which only one is conserved when the body changes shape.
Mark this sheet as read or add it to your favourites: a free account, no password, keeps your read sheets and favourites from one visit to the next, tells you which chapter to tackle next and lets you ask for the method or exercise you are missing. Create your space, an email is enough.
The thread of the chapter
A moment of inertia does not exist on its own: it exists ABOUT AN AXIS. As long as the axis is not named, no formula of the chapter makes sense, and that is where most of the lost marks come from.
•The constant-acceleration equations carry over unchanged: ω=ω0+αt, θ=ω0t+21αt2, ω2=ω02+2αθ.
•Links with a point of the body at distance r from the axis: v=ωr, at=αr, ac=ω2r.
•ALL angles are in RADIANS in these relations. A θ in degrees gives a wrong v by a factor of 57.3.
•at and ac are perpendicular: the total acceleration of a point is at2+ac2, never at alone.
Along the tangent, v=ωr and at=αr; toward the axis, ac=ω2r. The two accelerations are perpendicular: the total acceleration is their vector sum.
The dictionary is no substitute for thinking: I does not behave like m, since it changes when the axis changes, whereas mass never does.
Torque: it is not the distance that counts
•τ=rFsinϕ, where ϕ is the angle between r and F. Only the PERPENDICULAR component of the force makes the body turn.
•Another reading, often quicker: τ=F×d⊥, where d⊥ is the distance from the axis to the LINE OF ACTION of the force; this is the lever arm.
•A force whose line of action passes through the axis has ZERO torque, whatever its magnitude.
•The sign of the torque is fixed by convention: positive counterclockwise, and this convention holds for the whole problem.
•Στ=Iα is Newton's second law in rotation, and it is written about the SAME axis as the I used.
Three forces of the SAME magnitude at the SAME point: the perpendicular one turns at full effect, the oblique one according to its lever arm d⊥=rsin30°, the one aimed at the axis not at all.
On a wrench, pulling perpendicular to the handle is optimal; pulling along the handle tightens nothing at all, however hard you pull. The sine says so.
Moment of inertia, rolling, angular momentum
•Common values, about the axis of symmetry: hoop MR2; solid disc or cylinder 21MR2; solid sphere 52MR2; rod about its centre 121ML2; rod about one end 31ML2.
•Parallel-axis theorem: I=Icm+Md2, with d the distance between the new axis and the centre of mass. It applies ONLY from the axis through the centre of mass.
•Rolling without slipping: vcm=ωR and acm=αR, with K=21Mvcm2+21Iω2.
•On a descent, the ranking depends on neither mass nor radius, only on the ratio MR2I: sphere, then cylinder, then hoop, always in that order.
•L=Iω is conserved when Στext=0, EVEN if I changes along the way: this is the skater pulling her arms in.
Rolling without slipping: static friction starts at the point of contact, which is at rest, points up the slope and alone gives a torque about the centre; it does no work.
When I is halved at constant L, ω doubles and K=21Iω2 also DOUBLES: the energy comes from the skater's muscular work, it is not conserved.
Conservation of angular momentum: the skater
•L=Iω is conserved when no EXTERNAL torque acts about the axis; internal forces can change I without changing L.
•Arms pulled in: the mass moves closer to the axis, I decreases, and ω increases in the inverse ratio, ω2=I2I1ω1.
•The energy K=2IL2 increases in the same ratio: the work done by the arms supplies it.
View from above, same angular momentum: with arms out, the mass is far from the axis and the rotation is slow; with arms in, I drops and the rotation speeds up.
An object that jumps onto a merry-go-round brings its own angular momentum, mvd, with d its lever arm about the axis: it is the L of the complete system that is conserved.
The mistakes that cost marks
These are the errors I correct most often in session. Each one costs marks on a paper, even when the reasoning behind it is right.
1.Using a moment of inertia without saying about which axis
the whole question, 6 marks
What not to write
“The 2.0 kg, 1.2 m rod turns about a nail driven through one end: I=121ML2=0.24 kg·m2.”
What to write
“121ML2 holds for an axis through the CENTRE. Here the axis is at the end, so I=121ML2+M(2L)2=31ML2=0.96 kg·m2.”
Same rod, same mass, same length: only the pivot point changes, and the moment of inertia is multiplied by four. This is why a moment-of-inertia formula is never copied without checking the axis.
Why: The moment of inertia measures how the mass is distributed ABOUT A GIVEN AXIS. Changing the axis changes the result by a factor of 4 in this case, and all the dynamics with it.
2.Forgetting the sine, or confusing the distance with the lever arm
3 marks, and an angular acceleration almost twice too large
What not to write
“The 50 N force is applied 0.30 m from the axis, at 35° to the bar: τ=50×0.30=15 N·m.”
What to write
“τ=rFsin35°=0.30×50×0.574=8.6 N·m. The lever arm is 0.30sin35°=0.172 m, not 0.30 m.”
Why: Only the component perpendicular to the arm makes the body turn. The parallel component pulls on the axis, where the support takes it up entirely, with no effect on the rotation.
3.Keeping the same tension on both sides of a pulley that has mass
the whole question, 8 marks
What not to write
“Pulley of 2.0 kg, two masses joined: the rope has the same tension on both sides, so T1=T2.”
What to write
“If the pulley turns and has a moment of inertia, it is precisely the DIFFERENCE in tension that makes it turn: (T2−T1)R=Iα, so T2=T1.”
Why: Equal tensions are a consequence of I=0, not a property of pulleys. A statement that gives the mass of the pulley is telling you exactly not to use them.
4.Forgetting rotational energy in the energy balance of a rolling object
the whole question, 5 marks
What not to write
“The sphere rolls without slipping from a height h: mgh=21mv2, so v=2gh.”
What to write
“mgh=21mv2+21Iω2 with ω=Rv, so v=710gh, which is 85% of the speed of a frictionless slide.”
Why: A rolling body stores part of its energy in rotation. Answering 2gh amounts to saying that it slides without turning, which the statement has just ruled out.
5.Believing that mass or radius decides the race down an incline
4 marks on the reasoning questions
What not to write
“The big marble is heavier, so it arrives first.”
What to write
“The arrival speed is v=1+I/MR22gh: neither M nor R appears in it. Only the SHAPE counts, and the sphere always beats the cylinder, which always beats the hoop.”
Why: The ratio MR2I is 0.4 for a sphere, 0.5 for a cylinder and 1 for a hoop, whatever the mass and size. It is a pure number, specific to the geometry.
6.Conserving kinetic energy when the skater pulls her arms in
the whole reasoning question, 5 marks
What not to write
“Angular momentum is conserved, so kinetic energy is too: 21Iω2 stays constant.”
What to write
“L=Iω is conserved. If I is halved, ω doubles, and K=2IL2 DOUBLES. The skater supplied this work with her muscles.”
Why: Pulling the arms in requires a force directed toward the axis, which does work over a radial displacement. This work is internal, so it creates no torque, but it does add energy.
7.Treating the friction of rolling without slipping as dissipative
the whole question, 5 marks
What not to write
“The sphere rolls 3.0 m with friction, so f×3.0 must be subtracted from the energy balance.”
What to write
“In rolling WITHOUT slipping, the point of contact is at rest relative to the ground: the friction is STATIC, its point of application does not move, and it dissipates nothing.”
Why: The work done by a force is calculated at the point where it is applied. Here that point has zero velocity at every instant, hence zero work, even though the force is indispensable for making the sphere turn.
8.Working in degrees in v=ωr or in the angular equations
the whole question, and a result 57 times too large
What not to write
“The wheel turns 180° in 2.0 s: ω=90 deg/s, so v=90×0.30=27 m/s.”
What to write
“180°=π rad, so ω=1.57 rad/s and v=1.57×0.30=0.47 m/s.”
Why: The radian is the only dimensionless angle that makes v=ωr homogeneous. The error factor is exactly π180=57.3, and it shows up in the absurdity of the result.
9.Adding moments of inertia calculated about different axes
the whole question, 6 marks
What not to write
“The system is a rod plus a mass at the end: I=121ML2+mR2, with the rod about its centre and the mass about the axis.”
What to write
“All the terms must refer to the SAME axis. If the axis is the end of the rod: I=31ML2+mL2.”
Why: Moments of inertia add only about a common axis. Adding two numbers calculated about two different axes amounts to adding quantities that do not describe the same motion.
Which method to choose
Torque or energy
What the question asks for, exactly as in translation
If an angular acceleration, a time or a tension is asked for → Στ=Iα for the rotating body, plus ΣF=ma for the translating bodies
Example: Atwood machine with a massive pulley
If an angular velocity after a descent or a fall is asked for → energy balance with 21Iω2 included
Example: rod released from the horizontal, sphere rolling down a slope
If a speed after a CHANGE OF SHAPE of the system is asked for → conservation of angular momentum, I1ω1=I2ω2
Example: skater, platform on which someone walks
If an object falls onto a rotating disc and sticks to it → conservation of angular momentum, never of energy
Example: clay dropped on a turntable
If a contact force or an axle reaction is asked for → energy first for ω, then ΣF=macm with ac=ω2r
same sequence as in the energy chapter for the tension of a pendulum
The trigger phrase for conservation of angular momentum is always an internal change: “pulls her arms in”, “moves closer to the axis”, “sticks”, “comes off”. None of these events conserves kinetic energy.
Which moment of inertia to write
The geometry of the body AND the position of the axis, in that order
If the axis passes through the centre of symmetry → the formula from the table as it stands
Example: disc about its centre, 21MR2
If the axis is parallel to the previous one but offset by d → I=Icm+Md2
Example: rod about one end, 121ML2+M(2L)2=31ML2
If the body is made of several pieces → bring EACH piece to the same axis, then add
Example: rod plus point mass at the end: 31ML2+mL2
If the body is a point mass at distance r → I=mr2, with no coefficient at all
Example: ball on a string, satellite
If the statement gives the density and asks you to prove the formula → I=∫r2dm, with dm expressed in terms of dr or dx
this is the only question of the chapter where the integral calculus of 201-SN2-RE is used directly
Before writing anything, draw the axis and label it on the figure. A paper that shows the axis rarely picks the wrong formula; a paper that does not show it picks the wrong one every other time.
How the answer is expected to be written
A marker ticks steps. Here they are in order, with the concluding sentence expected word for word.
Solving a system with a pulley that has mass
When to use it: The statement gives the mass or the moment of inertia of the pulley, or says it is not ideal.
1Choose an assumed direction of motion and state it, then orient each axis in that direction, including the positive sense of rotation of the pulley.
2Draw one free-body diagram per mass, with DIFFERENT tensions on each side of the pulley.
3Write ΣF=ma for each mass, then Στ=Iα for the pulley, that is (T2−T1)R=Iα.
4Add the constraint of the non-slipping string: a=αR, which lets you replace α by Ra and brings out the term R2I.
5Add the three equations to eliminate the two tensions, obtain a, then work back to T1 and T2 separately.
Concluding sentence
“The three equations, added after substituting α=Ra, give a=m1+m2+I/R2(m2−m1)g=2.18 m/s2, then T1=35.9 N and T2=38.1 N.”
The trap: The term R2I has the dimensions of a MASS: it is the effective mass the pulley adds to the system. For a solid disc it is exactly 2M, which gives an immediate check of the result.
Marking: Typically 2 marks for the two diagrams, 2 for the pulley equation, 1 for the string constraint, 2 for the solution, 1 for the two distinct tensions.
Handling an angular momentum conservation problem
When to use it: The system changes shape, or a body joins a body that is already rotating.
1Justify the conservation: name the axis and say why no external torque acts about it, internal forces not counting.
2Calculate I1 in the initial state and I2 in the final state, bringing each piece to the SAME axis.
3Write I1ω1=I2ω2 and solve for the unknown.
4If the statement asks for it, calculate K1 and K2 separately and comment on the difference, naming its source.
Concluding sentence
“No external torque acts about the vertical axis, so L is conserved: I1ω1=I2ω2 gives ω2=6.0 rad/s, and the kinetic energy goes from 18 J to 36 J, the work of the muscles supplying the difference.”
The trap: Writing “the system is isolated” with no further detail. The weight and the axle reaction do exist: what must be said is that their TORQUE about the axis in question is zero.
Check before you hand in
Five minutes of checking recover more marks than one more problem started in a hurry.
The axis named on every moment of inertia
Go back over every I on the paper and write beside it the axis it refers to. Two I values for different axes in the same sum then jump out.
A 121ML2 in a problem where the nail is at the end: the axis does not match.
The term I/R2 read as a mass
In a pulley problem, check that this term really has the dimensions of a mass and that it equals 2M for a solid disc. It is a two-second check.
An I/R2=4.0 kg for a pulley of 2.0 kg: the moment of inertia used is not that of a disc.
The radian mode of the calculator
All the relations v=ωr, at=αr and θ=ωt require radians. Check RAD on the screen and convert the degrees in the statement on the very first line.
A speed of 27 m/s at the rim of a wheel that makes a half-turn in two seconds: factor 57, the angle stayed in degrees.
The comparison with a frictionless slide
A rolling body always arrives MORE SLOWLY than a body sliding without friction from the same height, since part of the energy has gone into rotation.
A rolling sphere arrives at 3.74 m/s where a pure slide would give 4.43 m/s: plausible. A value above 4.43 is not.
The order of arrival on an incline
Solid sphere, then solid cylinder, then hoop, whatever the mass and radius. Any answer that reverses this order, or that invokes the mass, is wrong.
A line of reasoning that concludes the heavier one wins: the result contains neither M nor R.
The typical problem, taken apart
Atwood machine with a pulley that has mass
Two blocks of masses m1=3.00 kg and m2=5.00 kg are joined by an inextensible string passing over a pulley modelled as a solid disc of mass M=2.00 kg and radius R=12.0 cm.
The string does not slip on the pulley and the axle is frictionless. Determine the acceleration of the blocks, then the two tensions in the string. Take g=9.80 m/s2.
The pulley is not a mere redirection: it turns, so it absorbs part of the acceleration, and the two strands of the string do NOT pull with the same force. It is this difference that sets it spinning.
Step 1
Assumed direction: m2 goes down, m1 goes up, the pulley turns in the corresponding direction. Moment of inertia: I=21MR2=21(2.00)(0.120)2=0.0144 kg·m2.
Why
The assumed direction fixes the sign of every term, including that of the torque. Without this statement, the sign of the Iα term cannot be justified.
Three bodies, three equations. Writing distinct T1 and T2 from the very first line avoids the costliest mistake here, and makes any further justification unnecessary.
Step 3
Constraint of the non-slipping string: a=αR, so α=Ra and the pulley equation becomes T2−T1=R2Ia=1.00a.
Why
The term R2I is 1.00 kg here: the pulley behaves exactly like an extra mass of 1.00 kg, half its real mass, which is the signature of the solid disc.
Step 4
Sum of the three equations: (m2−m1)g=(m1+m2+R2I)a, so a=3.00+5.00+1.00(5.00−3.00)(9.80)=9.0019.6=2.18 m/s2.
Why
The two tensions disappear by themselves because each appears twice with opposite signs. That is the only reason for orienting all the axes in the assumed direction of motion.
Step 5
T1=m1(g+a)=3.00(9.80+2.18)=35.9 N and T2=m2(g−a)=5.00(9.80−2.18)=38.1 N.
Why
Each tension is read from the equation of its own block, never from that of the pulley: the latter gives only their difference.
Step 6
Check with the pulley equation: T2−T1=38.1−35.9=2.18 N, to be compared with R2Ia=1.00×2.18=2.18 N.
Why
We check with the equation that was not used to isolate the results. Had the pulley been massless, this difference would have to be zero, which also gives the limiting case to test.
Step 7
Limiting case: with M=0, we would recover a=8.0019.6=2.45 m/s2 and T1=T2=36.8 N.
Why
The limiting case validates the structure of the formula: the massive pulley slows the system down and separates the tensions, exactly as the physics predicts.
The conclusion, written out
“The blocks accelerate at 2.18 m/s2, the strand supporting m1 is under 35.9 N and the one supporting m2 under 38.1 N, the difference of 2.18 N being exactly what sets the pulley spinning.”
The classic mistake on this problem: Setting T1=T2 from the start. You then get a=2.45 m/s2 and a single tension, and the mass of the pulley given in the statement was never used: an unused piece of data is almost always the sign of a wrong assumption.
Learn by heart
•A moment of inertia is ALWAYS given with its axis: 121ML2 at the centre, 31ML2 at the end.
•Parallel-axis theorem: I=Icm+Md2, and only from the axis through the centre of mass.
•τ=rFsinϕ: a force directed toward the axis has zero torque.
•Radians are compulsory in v=ωr, at=αr and ac=ω2r.
•Rolling without slipping: v=ωR, K=21Mv2+21Iω2, and static friction dissipates nothing.
•On a slope, the ranking depends only on MR2I: sphere 0.4, cylinder 0.5, hoop 1.
•Pulley with nonzero mass: T1=T2, and R2I adds like a mass in the denominator.
•L=Iω is conserved when Στext=0; K=2IL2, on the other hand, changes as soon as I changes.
Frequently asked questions
Why does the moment of inertia change with the chosen axis?
Because it measures how far from the axis the mass is distributed, and that distance changes with the axis. A rod turning about its centre has four times less inertia than the same rod turning about one end. The parallel-axis theorem lets you go from one to the other by adding the mass times the square of the offset.
When are the two tensions on a pulley different?
As soon as the pulley has mass and turns. It is precisely the gap between the two tensions that supplies the torque needed to set it spinning. An ideal massless pulley has zero moment of inertia and the two tensions are equal. If the statement gives the mass of the pulley, it is telling you not to confuse them.
Which object reaches the bottom of an incline first?
The solid sphere, ahead of the solid cylinder, ahead of the hoop, always in that order. Neither mass nor radius matters: all that counts is the ratio of the moment of inertia to the product of the mass and the square of the radius, which is two fifths, one half and one for these three shapes. The smaller this number, the less energy goes into rotation.
Why does a skater spin faster when she pulls her arms in?
Because angular momentum, the product of the moment of inertia and the angular velocity, is conserved when there is no external torque. By bringing her mass closer to the axis, she decreases her moment of inertia, so her angular velocity increases by the same factor. Her kinetic energy increases too: her muscles supply this work.
Does the friction on a rolling object dissipate energy?
No, as long as the rolling is without slipping. The point of contact is at rest relative to the ground at every instant, so the friction force does not move and does no work. It is still indispensable, since it creates the torque that makes the object turn.
Should rotation be done in degrees or radians?
In radians, without exception, in every relation that connects an angular quantity to a linear one. An angle in degrees gives a speed or an acceleration that is wrong by a factor of about fifty-seven. The first line of the paper should therefore convert the degrees given in the statement.
Practise it
Corrected exercises: Rotation of rigid bodies, 203-SN1-RE
A method is proved on a paper, not on a sheet. The set for the same chapter takes each of these traps into a problem, with the solution written out step by step.
Something missing from this sheet?A method, a trap, an exercise to practise it, a mistake you spotted: tell me, I read every request.
Sending goes through your free space: that is how I can answer you and tell you when the exercise is added. An email is enough, no password. Create your space.
Rather not create an account? Write to me directly.
Get in touch for a first session. Rotation is the chapter where analogies save time, as long as you never confuse the moment of inertia about one axis with that about another.