PHYS 101 Introductory Physics, Mechanics • McGill University, Montreal
Practice final exam, fully corrected (PHYS 101)
This is a practice final examination for PHYS 101, Introductory Physics, Mechanics, the algebra based first year course taken at McGill University by students heading into the life sciences. Twelve questions, four parts of twenty five points, three hours, calculator allowed. No derivative and no integral appears anywhere in these twelve solutions, because none appears anywhere in the course: every result is reached with algebra, proportions and the trigonometry of a right triangle.
The twelve questions are written as an exam, not as a revision sheet. Not one of them repeats a situation already solved in the twelve chapter sets of this site: the physics is the same, the story is new every time, which is the only way a practice paper measures anything. Each question carries its own Answers box, so a first pass can be marked in a few minutes, and the full reasoning sits underneath for the second pass.
The traps named explicitly in the solutions: converting kilometres per hour only once in a problem that needs it twice, reading a clearance as a landing, treating the normal force as the weight on a curved road, running an energy balance straight through a collision, forgetting that a hinge force does not point along the beam, computing a period from a length and then forgetting that the city changed g, adding two Doppler shifts instead of multiplying them, and feeding the image of the first lens into the second one with the wrong sign.
12 corrected exercises • 100 points
• 180 minutes
Part A: motion and forces (/25)
Exercise 1: A takeoff roll, an abort, and the climb that follows
An airliner needs a speed of 270 km/h to leave the ground. The runway available is 1800 m long and the aircraft starts from rest at its very beginning. Treat the acceleration along the runway as constant.
Take g=9.80 m/s2 throughout the paper. Nothing in this question needs a force: the whole of it is kinematics, unit conversion and the trigonometry of a right triangle.
a) Convert the takeoff speed to metres per second, then find the constant acceleration that uses exactly the 1800 m, and the time it takes.
b) At 150 km/h the captain aborts and brakes at a constant 3.5 m/s2. Find the total length of runway used, and the margin left.
c) After takeoff the aircraft climbs in a straight line at a constant 85 m/s, at 8.0∘ above the horizontal. Find the vertical and horizontal components of that velocity, the time needed to reach an altitude of 900 m, and the ground distance covered meanwhile.
d) Fully loaded, the same aircraft needs 2100 m to reach the same takeoff speed. Find the new acceleration and the new time, and say how each one scales with the runway length.
Show the solution
Answers
a)v=75.0 m/s, a=1.5625 m/s2, t=48.0 s
b)555.6+248.0=803.6 m used, margin 996 m
c)vy=11.83 m/s, vx=84.17 m/s, t=76.1 s, ground distance 6.40 km
d)a=1.339 m/s2 and t=56.0 s; a is inversely proportional to the length, t is directly proportional to it
a) One conversion, used twice. 270 km/h =270/3.6=75.0 m/s and 150 km/h =150/3.6=41.67 m/s. The equation that avoids the time is vf2=vi2+2aΔx, and with vi=0 it gives a=2Δxvf2=2(1800)75.02=36005625=1.5625 m/s2. Then t=vf/a=75.0/1.5625=48.0 s. Check it a second way with the average speed: the acceleration is constant and the start is from rest, so the average speed is 75.0/2=37.5 m/s and 1800/37.5=48.0 s. The trap here is not the physics, it is converting once and then writing 270 again in the next line: the number 270 has no place in any equation of this course.
b) Two phases, each with its own constant acceleration, so two separate applications of the same equation. Accelerating up to 41.67 m/s uses Δx1=2(1.5625)41.672=555.6 m. Braking from 41.67 m/s to rest at 3.5 m/s2 uses Δx2=2(3.5)41.672=248.0 m. Total 803.6 m, so 1800−804=996 m of runway are still ahead when the aircraft stops. Notice that the braking phase is shorter than the accelerating one even though both start or end at the same speed: the brakes are more than twice as strong as the engines, and distance goes as the inverse of the acceleration at fixed speed. The solution figure draws the whole abort as a velocity time graph, where the two distances are simply the areas of the two triangles.
c) The climb is a vector at 8.0∘ from the horizontal, so the two components come from a right triangle: vy=85sin8.0∘=85(0.13917)=11.83 m/s and vx=85cos8.0∘=85(0.99027)=84.17 m/s. The climb rate is the vertical component alone, so t=900/11.83=76.1 s, and during that time the ground distance is 84.17(76.1)=6.40×103 m. Check without the time at all: the path is a straight line, so ground distance =900/tan8.0∘=900/0.14054=6404 m. The two routes agree, which is the sign that the components were taken with the right trigonometric function. Writing vy=85cos8.0∘ would give a climb rate of 84 m/s, about seven times what any airliner can do: an order of magnitude check catches that mistake before the marker does.
d) Same final speed, longer runway, so a=2Δxvf2 gives a=2(2100)5625=1.339 m/s2 and t=75.0/1.339=56.0 s. Read the two formulas as proportions rather than recomputing: at fixed vf, a is inversely proportional to Δx, so a′=1.5625×21001800=1.339 m/s2; and t=2Δx/vf is directly proportional to Δx, so t′=48.0×18002100=56.0 s. Seventeen per cent more runway buys seventeen per cent more time and costs fourteen per cent of the acceleration.
Exercise 2: A volleyball serve that clears the net and still lands out
A player serves from a point 2.10 m above the floor, with a speed of 16.0 m/s directed 20.0∘ above the horizontal, straight down the court. The top of the net is 2.43 m above the floor and stands 9.00 m from the serve point, measured horizontally. The opponent's end line is 18.0 m from the serve point.
Air resistance is neglected, as it is everywhere in this course, and g=9.80 m/s2. The two motions are independent and share one clock.
a) Give the two components of the initial velocity, and the time at which the ball reaches the vertical plane of the net.
b) Find the height of the ball there, and say by how much it clears the net.
c) Find the total time of flight and the horizontal distance to the landing point. Is the serve in or out?
d) Find the speed and the direction of the velocity at landing, and check the speed a second way.
Show the solution
Answers
a)vx=15.04 m/s, vy0=5.472 m/s, t=0.599 s
b)y=3.620 m, it clears the net by 1.19 m
c)t=1.419 s and x=21.3 m, so the serve is out by 3.3 m
d)v=17.24 m/s, 29.3∘ below the horizontal
a) vx=16.0cos20.0∘=15.04 m/s and vy0=16.0sin20.0∘=5.472 m/s. The horizontal motion has no acceleration, so the net is reached when x=vxt=9.00, that is t=9.00/15.04=0.599 s. The horizontal column is always the one that carries the clock in this chapter, because it is the only one with a constant speed.
b) With the same clock, the vertical column gives y=2.10+5.472(0.599)−4.90(0.599)2=2.10+3.276−1.756=3.620 m. The clearance is 3.620−2.43=1.19 m. Note what the question did NOT ask: the ball is nowhere near the top of its flight at that instant, and computing the apex height would answer a different question. The apex is reached at t=vy0/g=0.558 s, slightly before the net, at a height of 3.628 m, so the ball crosses the net a few centimetres past its highest point and is already coming down.
c) Landing means y=0, so 4.90t2−5.472t−2.10=0. The discriminant is 5.4722+4(4.90)(2.10)=29.95+41.16=71.11, its square root is 8.432, and the physical root is the positive one, t=9.805.472+8.432=1.419 s. The negative root, −0.302 s, is the instant at which a ball launched from the floor would have passed through the serve point, which never happened. Then x=15.04(1.419)=21.3 m, and the end line is at 18.0 m: the serve is out by 3.3 m. Clearing the net and landing in are two different questions, and this serve answers yes to one and no to the other.
d) At landing vy=5.472−9.80(1.419)=−8.432 m/s, the minus sign saying downwards, while vx is still 15.04 m/s because nothing ever acted horizontally. So v=15.042+8.4322=17.24 m/s and the angle below the horizontal is arctan(8.432/15.04)=29.3∘. The second route needs no time at all: between the serve point and the floor the speed obeys v2=v02+2gh=16.02+2(9.80)(2.10)=256+41.16=297.2, so v=17.24 m/s. The two agree, and the second route is the energy idea of Part B arriving a chapter early.
Exercise 3: Three short scenes on forces: a load, a hilltop and a moon
Three independent situations, each one a standard use of Newton's second law. Take g=9.80 m/s2 on Earth.
SCENE 1. A crate of mass 85 kg sits on the flat open bed of a truck. The coefficients between crate and bed are μs=0.55 and μk=0.42. Nothing ties the crate down: the only horizontal force that can act on it is friction.
SCENE 2. A road crosses a hill whose top is a circular arc of radius R=42 m, drawn below. A car of mass 1150 kg drives over it, and one passenger has a mass of 68 kg.
SCENE 3. Io circles Jupiter on a nearly circular orbit of radius r=4.22×108 m with a period of 1.77 days. Take G=6.67×10−11 N m2/kg2 and the mass of the Earth as 5.97×1024 kg.
a) Scene 1. Find the largest deceleration the truck can have with the crate still riding along, and the shortest stop from 90 km/h that does not move the crate.
b) Scene 1. The driver instead brakes at 7.0 m/s2 from 90 km/h. Find the deceleration of the crate and how far it slides along the bed.
c) Scene 2. Find the speed at which the car just loses contact with the road at the top of the hill, in kilometres per hour.
d) Scene 2. At 15.0 m/s over the top, find the force the seat exerts on the 68 kg passenger, and express it as a fraction of the passenger's weight.
e) Scene 3. Find the mass of Jupiter, compare it with the mass of the Earth, and give the orbital speed of Io.
Show the solution
Answers
a)amax=5.39 m/s2 and a stop in 58.0 m
b)the crate decelerates at 4.12 m/s2 and slides 31.3 m, far longer than any truck bed
c)v=20.3 m/s, that is 73.0 km/h
d)N=302 N, which is 45.3 per cent of the weight
e)M=1.90×1027 kg, 319 times the Earth, v=17.3 km/s
a) The crate is not pushed by anything: the only force that can slow it down is the friction of the bed, so the crate can follow the truck only as long as the required force stays within what static friction can supply. ma≤μsmg gives a≤μsg=0.55(9.80)=5.39 m/s2, and the mass cancels, so a heavier crate is no safer. From 90 km/h =25.0 m/s the shortest such stop is Δx=2(5.39)25.02=58.0 m. Anything shorter and the load comes forward.
b) At 7.0 m/s2 the bed cannot hold the crate, so the crate slides and the friction switches to kinetic: the crate decelerates at only μkg=0.42(9.80)=4.12 m/s2. Both start at 25.0 m/s. The truck stops after 2(7.0)25.02=44.6 m; the crate needs 2(4.12)25.02=75.9 m, sliding on the stationary bed for the last part of it. The crate therefore advances 75.9−44.6=31.3 m relative to the truck, which is several times the length of any bed: it goes through the cab. The trap is to keep μs once the sliding has started, which would make the crate decelerate faster than it can.
c) At the top of the hill the centre of the circle is BELOW the car, so the net force must point downwards: mg−N=Rmv2. Contact is lost when N=0, that is v=gR=9.80(42)=20.3 m/s, or 73.0 km/h. Again the mass cancels. Compare this with a bucket swung in a vertical circle, where the same condition N=0 gives a MINIMUM speed, below which the load falls away from the path. Here the road can only push, never pull, so the same equation reads as a MAXIMUM: above 73.0 km/h the car leaves the road. Which of the two it is depends on which side of the path the support sits, not on the algebra.
d) For the passenger, mg−N=Rmv2, so N=m(g−Rv2)=68(9.80−4215.02)=68(9.80−5.357)=68(4.443)=302 N. As a fraction of the weight mg=666 N, that is 4.443/9.80=0.453: the seat pushes with only forty five per cent of its usual force, which is the lift in the stomach a passenger feels over a hump. Writing N=mg here is the standard loss of marks: N equals mg only when the acceleration perpendicular to the surface is zero, and on a curved road it never is.
e) Newton's second law along the radius for Io: r2GMm=T24π2mr, the mass of Io cancels, and M=GT24π2r3. With T=1.77(86400)=1.529×105 s and r3=7.515×1025 m3, the numerator is 2.967×1027 and the denominator is 6.67×10−11(2.339×1010)=1.560, so M=1.90×1027 kg, about 319 times the mass of the Earth. The orbital speed follows from the geometry alone: v=T2πr=1.73×104 m/s, that is 17.3 km/s. The lesson of this scene is that the mass of a planet is never weighed, it is read off the orbit of something that goes round it, and the orbiting body's own mass never enters the answer.
Part B: energy, momentum and rotation (/25)
Exercise 4: A spring plunger, a rough ramp, and the energy audit
A plunger holds a spring of stiffness k=900 N/m. It is pulled back, compressing the spring by 5.50 cm, and released against a ball of mass 0.0800 kg. The ball runs along a short frictionless horizontal rail and then goes up a ramp inclined at 12.0∘ and 1.20 m long.
The coefficients between ball and ramp are μk=0.10 and μs=0.15. Take g=9.80 m/s2. The elastic potential energy of a spring compressed by x is Ep=21kx2.
a) Find the energy stored in the spring, and explain in one sentence why it is 21kx2 and not kx⋅x.
b) Find the speed of the ball at the foot of the ramp.
c) Find its speed after it has climbed 0.45 m along the ramp, and give the share of the stored energy that went to height, to friction, and to motion.
d) The plunger is now pulled back only 2.00 cm. How far up the ramp does the ball go, does it stay there, and at what speed does it come back?
Show the solution
Answers
a)Ep=1.361 J, because the force grows from zero to kx, so the area under the force is a triangle
b)v=5.834 m/s
c)v=5.598 m/s; 5.39 per cent to height, 2.54 per cent to friction, 92.08 per cent still kinetic
d)it climbs 0.751 m, slides back down, and returns at 1.273 m/s
a) Ep=21(900)(0.0550)2=21(900)(0.003025)=1.361 J. The factor one half is not a convention: the force needed to hold the spring is F=kx, so it grows from 0 at the start of the compression to kx at the end. The work is the area under the force against displacement graph, and that area is a TRIANGLE of base x and height kx, not the rectangle kx⋅x. Using the rectangle doubles every energy in this question.
b) The rail is horizontal and frictionless, so every joule stored becomes kinetic: 21mv2=1.361 gives v=0.08002(1.361)=34.03=5.834 m/s. Notice what was not needed: the time of the push, the length of the plunger, the force at any instant. That is the whole point of an energy method.
c) Three terms, written once and for all. Height gained: Δh=0.45sin12.0∘=0.0936 m, so ΔEp=mgΔh=0.0800(9.80)(0.0936)=0.0734 J. Friction: the normal force on a slope is N=mgcosθ=0.0800(9.80)(0.97815)=0.7669 N, so f=μkN=0.0767 N and the energy it removes is fd=0.0767(0.45)=0.0345 J. What is left is kinetic: 1.361−0.0734−0.0345=1.253 J, hence v=0.08002(1.253)=5.598 m/s. The audit reads 5.39 per cent to height, 2.54 per cent to friction, 92.08 per cent still kinetic. The common error is to use N=mg on the slope, which raises the friction loss by two per cent of itself here, and by a great deal more on a steep ramp.
d) Now Ep=21(900)(0.0200)2=0.180 J. Going up, gravity and friction both oppose the motion, and both are constant along the slope, so the energy is spent at a fixed rate per metre: mgsinθ+μkmgcosθ=0.1630+0.0767=0.2397 N per metre. The ball stops after d=0.180/0.2397=0.751 m, well inside the 1.20 m ramp. Does it stay? Compare the pull down the slope, mgsinθ=0.163 N, with the largest static friction available, μsN=0.15(0.7669)=0.115 N. The pull wins, so the ball slides back. Coming down, gravity gives and friction still takes: (0.1630−0.0767)(0.751)=0.0648 J, so it returns at v=0.08002(0.0648)=1.273 m/s, against the 2.121 m/s it left with. Only 36.0 per cent of the stored energy survives the round trip, and friction took the rest, twice.
Exercise 5: Reconstructing a collision from the skid mark
A car A of mass 1400 kg runs into the back of a car B of mass 1100 kg stopped at a light. The two lock together and slide in a straight line for 14.0 m before stopping. The coefficient of kinetic friction between the locked wreck and the road is μk=0.70.
The speed limit on that street is 70 km/h and the driver of A says he was under it. Take g=9.80 m/s2.
a) Find the speed of the wreck just after the impact.
b) Find the speed of car A just before the impact, in metres per second and in kilometres per hour, and give the verdict.
c) Find the kinetic energy before and just after the impact, the fraction lost, and check that fraction against a formula.
d) The defence expert runs an energy balance straight through the impact instead. What speed does that give, and why is the method wrong?
Show the solution
Answers
a)v=13.86 m/s
b)vA=24.75 m/s, that is 89.1 km/h, 19 km/h over the limit
c)4.288×105 J before, 2.401×105 J after, 44.0 per cent lost, equal to mB/(mA+mB)
d)18.52 m/s, that is 66.7 km/h, under the limit and wrong: kinetic energy is not conserved in a collision where the bodies lock
a) The skid happens AFTER the collision, so it is a separate problem with one force, friction. Over the 14.0 m the friction removes all the kinetic energy: 21Mv2=μkMgd, the total mass cancels, and v=2μkgd=2(0.70)(9.80)(14.0)=192.1=13.86 m/s. That a 2500 kg wreck and a bicycle would skid the same distance from the same speed is not a paradox: a heavier body carries more energy and is held by more friction, in the same proportion.
b) The collision itself is where momentum, and only momentum, is conserved: mAvA=(mA+mB)v, so vA=14002500(13.86)=24.75 m/s. In the units of the traffic code that is 24.75(3.6)=89.1 km/h, about 19 km/h over the 70 km/h limit. Work backwards through the two stages in the right order, skid first and collision second, and never mix them.
c) Before: 21(1400)(24.75)2=4.288×105 J. Just after: 21(2500)(13.86)2=2.401×105 J. The loss is 1.886×105 J, that is 44.0 per cent, and it went into crushing metal, heat and sound. The check is worth remembering: for a perfectly inelastic collision with the target at rest the fraction lost is exactly mA+mBmB=25001100=0.440, independent of the speed. A heavy car hitting a light one loses little; a light car hitting a heavy one loses almost everything.
d) The expert writes 21(1400)vA2=2.401×105 and gets vA2=343.0, so vA=18.52 m/s =66.7 km/h, just under the limit. The number is arithmetically correct and physically worthless: the two cars lock together, which is the definition of a perfectly inelastic collision, and 44 per cent of the kinetic energy leaves the problem during the few hundredths of a second of the impact. Momentum survives that impact because the road exerts no significant horizontal impulse over so short a time; kinetic energy does not. Conserving the wrong quantity here is worth 22 km/h, and an acquittal.
Exercise 6: A hinged beam, a cable, and what happens when the cable snaps
A uniform beam of mass 40 kg and length 3.0 m is held horizontal by a hinge at a wall. A light cable runs from the far end of the beam back to the wall, making an angle of 35∘ with the beam. A sign of mass 25 kg hangs from a point 2.4 m from the hinge.
Take g=9.80 m/s2. Formulary, given: a uniform rod of mass M and length L turning about one end has I=31ML2, and a small body of mass m at a distance d from the axis has I=md2.
a) Find the tension in the cable, saying which axis you take torques about and why.
b) Find the horizontal and vertical components of the force the hinge exerts on the beam, then its magnitude and direction.
c) The cable snaps. Find the angular acceleration of the beam and sign at that instant.
d) Find the linear acceleration of the free end and of the sign just after the cable snaps, compare each with g, and say what that means.
Show the solution
Answers
a)T=683 N
b)Hx=560 N away from the wall, Hy=245 N up, so 611 N at 23.6∘ above the horizontal
c)α=4.45 rad/s2
d)13.4 m/s2 at the end and 10.7 m/s2 at the sign, both greater than g: beyond 2.2 m from the hinge the beam falls faster than a free body
a) Take torques about the HINGE, because that axis deletes the two unknown components of the hinge force and leaves T alone. Only the component of the cable tension perpendicular to the beam turns it, and that is Tsin35∘, applied at 3.0 m. Against it: the weight of the beam, 40(9.80)=392 N at the centre, 1.5 m out, and the sign, 25(9.80)=245 N at 2.4 m. So Tsin35∘(3.0)=392(1.5)+245(2.4)=588+588=1176 N m, giving Tsin35∘=392 N and T=392/0.5736=683 N. Using T itself instead of Tsin35∘, or using cos, is the most expensive single slip of the chapter.
b) Now the forces, in two directions. The cable pulls the end of the beam towards the wall with a horizontal component Tcos35∘=683(0.8192)=560 N, so the hinge must push the beam AWAY from the wall with the same 560 N. Vertically, Hy+Tsin35∘=(40+25)(9.80)=637 N, and since Tsin35∘=392 N exactly, Hy=245 N upwards. The magnitude is 5602+2452=611 N, at arctan(245/560)=23.6∘ above the horizontal. It does NOT point along the beam: a hinge is not a two force member, and only a rod with forces at its two ends only would have its force along its own line.
c) With the cable gone, nothing balances the torque of the two weights about the hinge, and that torque is still 1176 N m at the instant of the break, because nothing has moved yet. The moment of inertia about the hinge is I=31(40)(3.0)2+25(2.4)2=120+144=264 kg m2. Then α=I∑τ=2641176=4.45 rad/s2. Adding the two masses and treating the whole thing as a point body at some average distance gives a different and wrong number: in rotation a mass counts by the SQUARE of its distance.
d) a=αr, so the free end starts down at 4.45(3.0)=13.4 m/s2 and the sign at 4.45(2.4)=10.7 m/s2. Both are larger than g=9.80 m/s2. The crossover is at r=g/α=9.80/4.45=2.2 m: beyond that point the beam is driven down faster than gravity alone could do it, because the inner part of the beam is being held back by the hinge and pushes the outer part down through the rigid body. Put a coin on the beam at 2.8 m and cut the cable: the beam drops away from underneath the coin, which falls behind at a mere 9.80 m/s2. That is the classroom demonstration this question is built on.
Part C: oscillations, waves and sound (/25)
Exercise 7: A pendulum clock that changes season, then city
The pendulum of a grandfather clock is a rod of length L=0.9930 m carrying a small dense bob, and it is regulated in Montreal, where g=9.80 m/s2. The escapement moves the second hand by one second at each half swing, so the clock keeps correct time when its period is exactly 2.000 s.
Take the pendulum as simple, T=2πL/g, with the bob small compared with the rod and the angle small enough for the formula to hold. A day is 86400 s.
a) Find the period and the frequency of this pendulum, and say whether the clock keeps time.
b) In summer the brass rod is 0.040 per cent longer. Find the new period and the number of seconds the clock loses in a day.
c) The clock is shipped to Quito, where g=9.771 m/s2. At the original length, how much does it lose in a day, and by how much must the rod be shortened to put it right?
d) The bob has mass 0.250 kg and swings with an angular amplitude of 6.0∘. Find the maximum speed of the bob in two independent ways and compare them.
Show the solution
Answers
a)T=2.000 s and f=0.500 Hz, so the clock keeps time
b)T=2.0004 s, and it loses 17.3 s per day
c)it loses 128 s per day, and the rod must be shortened by 2.9 mm
d)vmax=0.3267 m/s by the oscillator formula and 0.3265 m/s by energy, agreeing to 0.05 per cent
a) T=2π9.800.9930=2π0.101327=2π(0.318318)=2.000 s, so f=1/T=0.500 Hz. The clock keeps time. Two things do NOT appear in that formula and are worth saying out loud, because half the marks of this chapter live there: the mass of the bob, and the amplitude. A heavier bob and a wider swing both leave the period alone.
b) Lengthening by 0.040 per cent means L′=1.00040L. Since T∝L, the period grows by 1.00040=1.000200, so T′=2.0004 s. Do not stop there: the question asks for seconds lost, not for a period. In one real day of 86400 s the clock displays 86400×T′T=86400(0.999800)=86383 s, so it loses 17.3 s. A useful shortcut for the checking pass: a fractional change of L gives half as large a fractional change of T, and half of 0.040 per cent of a day is 0.00020(86400)=17 s.
c) In Quito T′′=2π9.7710.9930=2.0030 s, and the display falls behind by 86400(1−2.00302.0000)=128 s, over two minutes a day. To fix it the rod must be shortened until the period is 2.000 s again with the smaller g: Lnew=4π2gT2=39.4789.771(4.000)=0.99006 m, that is 2.9 mm shorter. The half rule checks it: g dropped by 0.296 per cent, so L must drop by the same 0.296 per cent, which is 0.9930(0.00296)=2.9 mm. The trap is to change the city and keep the old g in the formula, which is the single most common way to lose this question.
d) First route, the oscillator formula. The angular amplitude is θ0=6.0∘=0.10472 rad, so the linear amplitude along the arc is A=Lθ0=0.9930(0.10472)=0.10399 m, and with ω=T2π=3.1416 rad/s the maximum speed is vmax=ωA=0.3267 m/s. Second route, energy, which uses no small angle approximation at all: the bob rises h=L(1−cos6.0∘)=0.9930(0.0054781)=0.005440 m at the ends of the swing, so v=2gh=0.10662=0.3265 m/s. The two differ by 0.05 per cent, which is exactly the size of the error the small angle approximation commits at 6∘. Neither route needs the mass, and a solution that carries 0.250 kg into the answer has gone wrong somewhere.
Exercise 8: The resonance tube, and the correction nobody expects
A vertical tube 95 cm long stands in a tall jar; a tap lets the water level inside it fall slowly. A tuning fork marked 512 Hz is held over the open top, and the air column below it sounds loudly at certain lengths and stays quiet in between. The column is open at the top and closed by the water at the bottom.
Two resonances are recorded, at air column lengths L1=15.9 cm and L2=49.4 cm, both measured from the open top down to the water. The speed of sound in air is v=331+0.60TC in metres per second, with TC in degrees Celsius. An end correction e of about 0.6 times the tube radius must be added to the measured length to get the acoustic length.
a) Explain why two successive resonances are half a wavelength apart, then give the wavelength and the speed of sound.
b) Find the temperature of the room.
c) Find the end correction, and from it estimate the diameter of the tube.
d) Predict every water level at which this fork resonates in the 95 cm tube, and say how many resonances a 256 Hz fork would give in the same tube.
Show the solution
Answers
a)λ=0.670 m and v=343 m/s
b)TC=20 degrees Celsius
c)e=0.85 cm, so the tube is about 2.8 cm across
d)resonances at 15.9, 49.4 and 82.9 cm; the 256 Hz fork gives only one, at 32.7 cm
a) A closed pipe carries a displacement node at the water and an antinode at the open top, so it resonates when the acoustic length is an ODD number of quarter wavelengths: λ/4, 3λ/4, 5λ/4. The gap between two successive ones is therefore 43λ−4λ=2λ, and the end correction cancels in that subtraction, which is exactly why the experiment is done with a DIFFERENCE and not with a single length. So 2λ=0.494−0.159=0.335 m, λ=0.670 m, and v=fλ=512(0.670)=343 m/s.
b) 343=331+0.60TC gives TC=12/0.60=20 degrees Celsius, an ordinary laboratory. This is the check that catches a slipped decimal: any speed of sound outside roughly 320 to 360 m/s means the wavelength was read wrong, because no teaching laboratory is at minus twenty or at plus sixty degrees.
c) Now use a single length, where the correction does not cancel. The first resonance should sit at λ/4=0.1675 m but was found at 0.159 m, so e=0.1675−0.159=0.0085 m, that is 0.85 cm. With e≈0.6r the radius is r=0.85/0.6=1.4 cm and the tube is about 2.8 cm across, which a ruler across the top confirms. The antinode is not exactly at the rim: the air just above the tube takes part in the oscillation, and that is the whole content of the end correction.
d) The levels are given by Ln=4(2n−1)λ−e with n=1,2,3: 16.75−0.85=15.9 cm, 50.25−0.85=49.4 cm, and 83.75−0.85=82.9 cm, all inside the 95 cm tube. The fourth would need 117.25−0.85=116 cm, longer than the tube, so three resonances and no more. A 256 Hz fork has λ=343/256=1.34 m, twice as long, so its first resonance is at 33.5−0.85=32.7 cm and its second would need 100.5−0.85=99.7 cm: only ONE resonance fits. Halving the frequency doubles the wavelength and therefore halves the number of resonances a given tube can show, which is why the low fork is the frustrating one in the laboratory.
Exercise 9: A wave given as a formula, and two trains that pass
SCENE 1. A wave travels along a long rope and every point of the rope obeys y=0.0400sin(12.6x−251t), with x and y in metres and t in seconds. The general form used in the course is y=Asin(kx−ωt), with k=λ2π and ω=2πf.
SCENE 2. Two trains run towards each other on parallel tracks. The first sounds a horn of frequency 520 Hz and moves at 30.0 m/s; the second moves at 20.0 m/s. The speed of sound is 343 m/s and the Doppler formula of the course is f′=fv∓vsv±vo, the upper signs applying when the motion brings source and observer together.
a) Read off A, k and ω, then give λ, f, T and the wave speed, and say in which direction the wave travels.
b) Find the greatest speed reached by a single point of the rope, and say why it is not the speed of the wave.
c) Find the displacement of the point at x=0.200 m at the instant t=0.0100 s, and the tension in the rope if its linear density is μ=0.0120 kg/m.
d) Find the frequency heard by a passenger in the second train while the two approach.
e) Find the frequency heard once they have passed, give the size of the drop, and say why the two motions cannot simply be dealt with one at a time and added.
Show the solution
Answers
a)A=0.0400 m, λ=0.499 m, f=39.9 Hz, T=0.0250 s, v=19.9 m/s in the +x direction
b)vmax=10.0 m/s, about half the wave speed
c)y=+0.400 mm and the tension is 4.76 N
d)f′=603 Hz
e)f′=450 Hz, a drop of 153 Hz; the two effects multiply, they do not add
a) Compare term by term with y=Asin(kx−ωt): A=0.0400 m, k=12.6 rad/m, ω=251 rad/s. Then λ=k2π=12.66.2832=0.499 m, f=2πω=6.2832251=39.9 Hz, T=1/f=0.0250 s, and v=kω=12.6251=19.9 m/s, which also equals fλ. The sign between the two terms fixes the direction: a MINUS means the pattern moves towards positive x, because to keep kx−ωt constant, x must grow as t grows. A plus sign would have meant the other way.
b) A point of the rope does not travel with the wave; it goes up and down about its own place, in simple harmonic motion of amplitude A and angular frequency ω. So its greatest speed is vmax=ωA=251(0.0400)=10.0 m/s, reached each time it crosses y=0. That is about half the 19.9 m/s at which the SHAPE advances, and the two numbers describe different things: one is a piece of rope moving across the rope, the other is a pattern moving along it. Nothing forbids vmax from exceeding the wave speed, and a rope shaken harder would do it.
c) Put the numbers in: 12.6(0.200)−251(0.0100)=2.52−2.51=0.0100 rad, a number of RADIANS and not of degrees, so y=0.0400sin(0.0100)=0.0400(0.0100)=4.00×10−4 m, that is +0.400 mm, a point just leaving its rest position on the way up. A calculator left in degree mode returns 0.0400sin(0.01∘), roughly 7×10−6 m, and is wrong by a factor of 57. The tension comes from v=T/μ: T=μv2=0.0120(19.92)2=4.76 N.
d) Both move, and both move in the sense that closes the gap, so both signs help: the observer moves into the waves, which raises the numerator, and the source chases its own waves, which lowers the denominator. f′=520343−30.0343+20.0=520313363=520(1.1597)=603 Hz.
e) After the crossing both motions widen the gap, so both signs reverse: f′=520343+30.0343−20.0=520373323=450 Hz. The drop across the crossing is 603−450=153 Hz, close to a musical fourth, and it happens in the moment the trains pass, which is why the pitch of a passing horn falls suddenly instead of sliding down. Why not treat the two motions separately? Moving the source alone gives 570 Hz, moving the observer alone gives 550 Hz, and neither the sum of the two shifts, 50+30=80 Hz, nor anything else additive reproduces the real shift of 83 Hz. The two effects enter as a RATIO of two factors, one in the numerator and one in the denominator, so they multiply: 570×343363=603 Hz. Treating the moving source and the moving observer as interchangeable is the other classic slip, and the two numbers just computed, 570 and 550 Hz, show that they are not.
Part D: optics (/25)
Exercise 10: Two lenses on the same bench
On an optical bench, a lit arrow 1.2 cm tall stands at the 35.0 cm mark. A converging lens L1 of focal length f1=+10.0 cm sits at the 50.0 cm mark and a second converging lens L2 of focal length f2=+15.0 cm at the 100 cm mark.
Sign convention, written once: do1+di1=f1 and m=−dodi, with di>0 for a real image on the outgoing side of the lens and di<0 for a virtual image on the incoming side.
a) Find the image formed by L1 alone: its position on the bench, its magnification and its nature. Then state the rule that links the two lenses.
b) Find the final image: its position on the bench, the total magnification, its nature and its height.
c) The two lenses are now brought to a separation of 40.0 cm, L2 being moved to the 90.0 cm mark. Find the new final image.
d) Back to the 100 cm mark, L2 is replaced by a diverging lens of focal length −15.0 cm. Find the final image.
Show the solution
Answers
a)di1=+30.0 cm, at the 80.0 cm mark, m1=−2.00, real and inverted; that image is the object of the second lens
b)di2=+60.0 cm, at the 160 cm mark, m=+6.00, real, upright with respect to the original arrow, 7.2 cm tall
c)di2=−30.0 cm, a virtual image at the 60.0 cm mark, m=−6.00, inverted, 7.2 cm tall
d)di2=−8.57 cm, a virtual image at the 91.4 cm mark, m=−0.857, inverted, 1.03 cm tall
a) For L1, do=50.0−35.0=15.0 cm, so di=do−fdof=15.0−10.015.0(10.0)=+30.0 cm: a real image 30.0 cm past L1, that is at the 80.0 cm mark, with m1=−15.030.0=−2.00, inverted and twice as tall. The rule that makes a two lens problem tractable is that the image formed by the first lens becomes the OBJECT of the second, real or not, and light does not care that no screen was put there. Only one thing needs watching: if that intermediate image had landed BEYOND L2, the second lens would have a virtual object and do would be negative. Here it lands before L2, so do is positive.
b) The intermediate image sits at the 80.0 cm mark and L2 at 100 cm, so do2=20.0 cm. Then di2=20.0−15.020.0(15.0)=+60.0 cm, a real image 60.0 cm past L2, at the 160 cm mark, where a screen would catch it. m2=−20.060.0=−3.00, and the total magnification is the PRODUCT, m=m1m2=(−2.00)(−3.00)=+6.00. Two inversions make an upright image: the final arrow points the same way as the original one and is 1.2(6.00)=7.2 cm tall. Adding the magnifications instead of multiplying them is the standard error and gives −5, wrong in size and in sign.
c) With L2 at the 90.0 cm mark, the intermediate image is unchanged at 80.0 cm, so do2=10.0 cm, which is INSIDE the focal length of L2. Then di2=10.0−15.010.0(15.0)=−30.0 cm: a virtual image 30.0 cm on the incoming side, at the 60.0 cm mark. m2=−10.0−30.0=+3.00 and m=−6.00: same size as before, 7.2 cm, but inverted and virtual, so no screen will show it. Moving a lens by ten centimetres turned a real image into a virtual one, which is the whole content of the second half of the chapter.
d) With f2=−15.0 cm and do2=20.0 cm, di2=20.0−(−15.0)20.0(−15.0)=35.0−300=−8.57 cm, a virtual image 8.57 cm on the incoming side of L2, at the 91.4 cm mark. m2=−20.0−8.57=+0.429 and m=(−2.00)(+0.429)=−0.857, so the final arrow is inverted and 1.2(0.857)=1.03 cm tall, slightly smaller than the original. A diverging lens alone can never give anything but a reduced virtual upright image, but placed second in a chain it can perfectly well leave the final image inverted, because the first lens had already turned it over.
Exercise 11: A double slit read inside its single slit envelope
A helium neon laser of wavelength 633 nm lights a pair of slits whose centres are d=0.250 mm apart, each slit being a=0.0500 mm wide. The screen is L=3.00 m behind the slits.
Two conditions are at work at the same time. The two slits interfere, giving bright fringes where dsinθ=mλ; and each slit diffracts on its own, giving darkness where asinθ=pλ with p a non zero whole number. The angles are small enough for sinθ≈tanθ=y/L.
a) Find the spacing between neighbouring bright fringes on the screen.
b) Find which interference orders are missing, and explain why they are.
c) Find the full width of the central diffraction envelope, and how many bright fringes lie inside it.
d) One of the two slits is now covered. Say what changes on the screen and what does not.
Show the solution
Answers
a)Δy=7.60 mm
b)the orders m=5, 10, 15 and so on are missing, because d/a=5
c)the central envelope is 76.0 mm wide and holds 9 bright fringes
d)the fringes disappear, the envelope keeps exactly the same width, and the screen gets much dimmer
a) Δy=dλL=0.250×10−3(633×10−9)(3.00)=7.60×10−3 m, that is 7.60 mm. Keep every length in metres before dividing: mixing nanometres and millimetres in the same fraction is the way three orders of magnitude go missing without anything looking wrong.
b) A bright fringe of order m sits at sinθ=mλ/d, and a diffraction dark point at sinθ=pλ/a. When the two angles coincide the interference maximum falls exactly where one slit alone sends no light at all, so nothing arrives and the fringe is MISSING. Setting dmλ=apλ gives m=pad=5p, so m=5,10,15,… are missing on each side. The ratio d/a=5 is a whole number here, which is why the effect is clean; with d/a=4.3 no order would vanish completely.
c) The first diffraction minimum is at sinθ=aλ=0.0500×10−3633×10−9=0.01266, so y=Lsinθ=3.00(0.01266)=0.0380 m =38.0 mm on each side, and the central envelope is 76.0 mm wide. Inside it the fringes are 7.60 mm apart, and 38.0/7.60=5 exactly, which says that the missing order m=5 is the envelope edge itself. What survives is the central fringe plus orders 1 to 4 on each side: 9 bright fringes, of quickly fading brightness, as the solution figure shows. Swapping the roles of d and a in these two formulas is the single most common mistake of the chapter: the SMALL opening, a, controls the big feature, and the big spacing, d, controls the fine one.
d) Covering one slit removes the interference, because interference needs two beams to add. The regular 7.60 mm fringes vanish. What stays is the diffraction pattern of the surviving slit alone, whose central bright band is still 76.0 mm wide, because that width depends on a and on nothing else, and a has not changed. The screen also becomes much darker, since half the light is now blocked and the bright fringes were four times the brightness of one slit rather than twice. The experiment therefore separates cleanly: d owns the fringes, a owns the envelope.
Exercise 12: Synthesis: a weighted string, a falling ball and a turning wheel
Three short scenes, each one built from two different chapters of the course. Take g=9.80 m/s2.
SCENE 1. A wire of linear density μ=0.80 g/m runs horizontally over two bridges 0.750 m apart, passes over a frictionless pulley and is tensioned by a block of mass 2.0 kg resting on a FRICTIONLESS incline at 30.0∘, the cord running parallel to the incline.
SCENE 2. A converging lens of focal length +20.0 cm has its axis horizontal. A small ball is released from rest at a point level with the axis and 60.0 cm in front of the lens, and falls in a vertical plane at that same distance from the lens.
SCENE 3. A wheel of radius R=0.350 m turns at a constant 2.50 revolutions per second. A lamp far away on the left throws the shadow of one point of the rim onto a vertical screen on the right.
a) Scene 1. Find the tension in the wire and the speed of waves along it.
b) Scene 1. Find the fundamental frequency of the 0.750 m segment and the mass that would raise it to 100 Hz.
c) Scene 2. Find the image distance and the magnification, then the displacement of the image while the ball falls for 0.300 s, and its direction.
d) Scene 2. Find the average speed of the image over that interval, and the instant at which the image is moving at 1.00 m/s.
e) Scene 3. Give the amplitude, the period and the maximum speed of the shadow, and compare that speed and the shadow's maximum acceleration with the rim speed and the centripetal acceleration.
Show the solution
Answers
a)T=9.80 N and v=110.7 m/s
b)f1=73.8 Hz, and 3.67 kg would give 100 Hz
c)di=30.0 cm and m=−0.500; the image moves 22.05 cm upwards while the ball falls 44.1 cm
d)0.735 m/s on average, and the image reaches 1.00 m/s at t=0.204 s
e)A=0.350 m, T=0.400 s, vmax=5.50 m/s, equal to the rim speed; and amax=86.4 m/s2, equal to the centripetal acceleration
a) The tension is not mg: the block rests on an incline, and along the frictionless slope the only two forces are the cord and the component of the weight, so T=mgsin30.0∘=2.0(9.80)(0.500)=9.80 N. Then v=μT=8.0×10−49.80=12250=110.7 m/s. This is the whole point of the scene: the wave question cannot start until a Part A free body diagram has been drawn. Writing T=mg=19.6 N gives v=156.5 m/s and a fundamental of 104 Hz, forty per cent too high.
b) A segment fixed at both ends has λ1=2L, so f1=2Lv=1.500110.7=73.8 Hz, and the third harmonic would be 3(73.8)=221 Hz. For 100 Hz, work by proportion: f∝v∝T∝m, so m′=2.0(73.8100)2=2.0(1.837)=3.67 kg. Check it the long way: f1=100 needs v=2Lf1=150 m/s, hence T=μv2=8.0×10−4(22500)=18.0 N, hence m=9.80(0.500)18.0=3.67 kg. The two agree.
c) The ball falls in a plane at a FIXED distance from the lens, so do=60.0 cm never changes and neither does the image: di=60.0−20.060.0(20.0)=+30.0 cm and m=−60.030.0=−0.500. In 0.300 s the ball falls h=21(9.80)(0.300)2=0.441 m =44.1 cm, so the image moves 0.500(44.1)=22.05 cm. The minus sign of m says the image moves the OTHER way: the ball goes down, the image goes up.
d) Because m is a fixed number, every displacement of the ball is copied by the image at half size, and therefore so is every speed, at every instant: no calculus is needed and none is allowed. Over the 0.300 s the ball's average speed is 0.30044.1=147 cm/s, so the image averages 73.5 cm/s, that is 0.735 m/s. For the image to move at 1.00 m/s the ball must be falling at 2.00 m/s, which happens at t=9.802.00=0.204 s, by then 0.204 m below its starting point. A camera focused on this lens records a picture that accelerates at half of g, which is how high speed films of falling objects are calibrated.
e) Uniform circular motion seen edge on IS simple harmonic motion: the shadow of the rim point obeys x=Rcos(ωt), so its amplitude is the radius itself, A=0.350 m. With 2.50 revolutions per second, ω=2π(2.50)=15.71 rad/s and T=0.400 s. Then vmax=ωA=15.71(0.350)=5.50 m/s and amax=ω2A=246.7(0.350)=86.4 m/s2. Compare: the rim point itself travels at v=ωR=5.50 m/s and has a centripetal acceleration ω2R=86.4 m/s2, that is 8.8 times g. The two pairs are equal, and not by accident. The shadow reaches its greatest speed as the rim point crosses the middle, where that point is moving straight along the screen and the shadow keeps all of its speed; and the shadow has its greatest acceleration at the two ends, where the centripetal acceleration points straight along the screen. The oscillator formulas of Part C and the rotation formulas of Part B are two readings of the same circle.