This sheet is not a summary of sections 11.8 and 11.9 of Stewart: you already have the course notes. It answers one question only, what makes students lose marks on power series in MATH 141 at McGill University, and which precise gesture avoids each loss.
Every number below is done by hand, as on the exam, and every value quoted has been checked by an independent computation. The rule that runs through the whole sheet: the radius comes from one test, each endpoint from its own.
Mark this sheet as read or add it to your favourites: a free account, no password, keeps your read sheets and favourites from one visit to the next, tells you which chapter to tackle next and lets you ask for the method or exercise you are missing. Create your space, an email is enough.
The thread of the chapter
The ratio test finds the RADIUS, never the interval: each endpoint is a separate numerical series with its own test, every operation on a series (substitute, recentre, multiply by a power of x, differentiate, integrate) keeps track of R but not of the endpoints, and outside the interval the series is worth nothing, even where the function exists.
•A power series ∑cn(x−a)n converges absolutely for ∣x−a∣<R and diverges for ∣x−a∣>R. It always converges at its centre a; R can be 0 or ∞.
•R: ratio test on ∣an∣ with x fixed, anan+1→R∣x−a∣. When every factor is a power n, the root test is faster.
•At ∣x−a∣=R the ratio limit is exactly 1: the test is silent BY CONSTRUCTION. Substitute x=a−R and x=a+R, write the two numerical series, test each one.
•Four possible answers: (a−R,a+R), [a−R,a+R), (a−R,a+R], [a−R,a+R]. Only the endpoint tests choose between them.
•Read the centre after factoring: (2x−3)n=2n(x−23)n, centre 23, and ∣2x−3∣<1 gives R=21.
For ∑n2n(x−1)n the ratio test gives only (−1,3); the alternating series test closes the bracket at −1, the p-series ∑n1 leaves it open at 3.
The midpoint of the interval must be the centre, and its half-length the radius: a ten-second check that catches every misread centre.
Everything comes from 1/(1 - u)
•1−u1=∑n=0∞un for ∣u∣<1, and never at ∣u∣=1. Put the function in the form 1−uconstant and read u: the interval is ∣u∣<1.
•Create the 1 by factoring: 2+x1=21⋅1+x/21=∑2n+1(−1)nxn, ∣x∣<2.
•Recentre at a by rewriting around a: x+51=7+(x−2)1=∑7n+1(−1)n(x−2)n, ∣x−2∣<7.
•Differentiate or integrate term by term inside (a−R,a+R): same R, endpoints re-tested, and a constant C found at the centre.
•ln(1+x)=∑n≥1(−1)n+1nxn on (−1,1], arctanx=∑n≥0(−1)n2n+1x2n+1 on [−1,1], (1−x)21=∑n≥0(n+1)xn on (−1,1).
On (−1,1) the partial sums S1, S3, S6 of ∑xn close in on 1−x1; outside the dashed lines x=±1 they run away, whatever the function does.
The rules in table form
Each row reads from left to right: the assumptions, then the result. A red cell is not an answer, it is the finding that the form settles nothing and the instruction to rewrite it. Every case is followed by a worked example.
What each operation does to the radius and to the endpoints
Start from a series of radius R. The left column is the operation, the middle one what happens to R, the right one what the endpoints need afterwards. The red line is the only one that produces no value at all.
Example: ∑n2xn on [−1,1] gives ∑nxn−1 on [−1,1).
integrate
unchanged
may GAIN an endpoint
Example: 1+x21 on (−1,1) gives arctanx on [−1,1].
evaluate at ∣x−a∣>R
not applicable
the series divergesno value
Example: ln(1+x) at x=2: the terms n2n tend to ∞, so the series is not ln3.
Same form, other result: 1−x1 at x=−21: ∑(−21)n=32, correct; at x=−2: ∑(−2)n diverges while 1−(−2)1=31.
What to do: Find another series, or another point, inside its interval: ln3=−ln(1−32)=∑n(2/3)n.
The radius column is a free result from the theorem or from ∣u∣<1; the endpoint column is always work to do on the copy.
The mistakes that cost marks
These are the errors I correct most often in session. Each one costs marks on a paper, even when the reasoning behind it is right.
1.Giving the open interval as the answer
2 marks, the two endpoint marks of the question
What not to write
“anan+1→3∣x∣<1, so the interval of convergence of ∑n3nxn is (−3,3).”
What to write
“R=3. At x=3: ∑n1 diverges. At x=−3: ∑n(−1)n converges by the alternating series test. Interval [−3,3).”
The ratio test gives the open interval (−3,3). Each endpoint is then tested on its own: closed at −3 (green), open at 3 (red), so the interval is [−3,3).
Why: The ratio test decides only strictly inside and strictly outside. The endpoints are two more series, and the answer is not complete until each has a verdict with its test named.
2.Testing an endpoint with the ratio test
1 mark per endpoint
What not to write
“At x=3, limanan+1=1, so the series diverges there.”
What to write
“At x=3 the ratio limit is 1, which decides nothing. The series is ∑n1, a p-series with p=1: it diverges.”
Why: L=1 is the silent case of the ratio test, and at an endpoint it is 1 by construction. The conclusion must come from a test that CAN decide: divergence test, p-series, comparison, alternating series test.
3.Misreading the centre or the radius
the whole question, since every endpoint is then wrong
What not to write
“∑n(2x−3)n is centred at 3 with radius 1.”
What to write
“(2x−3)n=2n(x−23)n: centre 23, and ∣2x−3∣<1⟺x−23<21, so R=21 and the interval is [1,2).”
(2x−3)n=2n(x−23)n: centre 23, radius 21, interval [1,2) (green). Reading the centre 3 and radius 1 off (2x−3) (red) misplaces both.
Why: The centre is the point where the base of the power vanishes, and the radius is measured in x, not in 2x. The check: the midpoint of [1,2) is 23 and its half-length 21.
4.Evaluating a series outside its interval
the whole question
What not to write
“1−x1=∑xn, so at x=−1.5 the series gives 2.51=0.4.”
What to write
“The identity holds only for ∣x∣<1. At x=−1.5 the terms (−1.5)n grow without bound: the series diverges, although 1−x1=0.4 exists.”
Left of the dashed line x=−1, S4 and S5 leave 1−x1 in opposite directions, although the function is perfectly smooth there.
Why: A power series knows its function only inside its interval. Beyond it the partial sums swing further and further from the function, and no value can be read off them.
5.Forgetting the constant after integrating
1 to 2 marks
What not to write
“dxdln(3+x)=3+x1=∑3n+1(−1)nxn, so ln(3+x)=∑(n+1)3n+1(−1)nxn+1.”
What to write
“ln(3+x)=C+∑(n+1)3n+1(−1)nxn+1, and at x=0: ln3=C. So ln(3+x)=ln3+∑n≥0(n+1)3n+1(−1)nxn+1 on (−3,3].”
Why: Term-by-term integration gives an antiderivative, so a constant. At the centre the series is worth 0 and the function ln3: the check at x=0 finds C in one line.
6.Differentiating a number instead of a function
the whole question
What not to write
“∑n≥0(31)n=23, and the derivative of 23 is 0, so ∑n≥1n(31)n−1=0.”
What to write
“On (−1,1), ∑n≥1nxn−1=(1−x)21; at x=31 this gives 49, so ∑3nn=31⋅49=43.”
Why: Differentiation acts on functions of x. Keep x a variable until the identity between functions is established, and substitute the number on the last line only.
7.Assuming a derived series keeps its endpoints
1 mark per endpoint
What not to write
“∑nxn converges on [−1,1), so its derivative ∑xn−1 converges on [−1,1) too, by the theorem.”
What to write
“The theorem gives the same radius 1. At x=−1, ∑(−1)n−1 has terms that do not tend to 0: it diverges. The derivative converges on (−1,1).”
Same radius 1 on all three lines, three different brackets: the derivative loses x=−1, the antiderivative gains x=1.
Why: Differentiating multiplies the nth term by n, which can only make things worse at an endpoint; integrating divides by n+1, which can only help. The theorem speaks about R, never about the brackets.
8.A coefficient formula on a series with missing powers
the whole question
What not to write
“∑4nx2n has cn=4n1, so R=limcn+1cn=4.”
What to write
“Ratio test on the terms: anan+1=4x2<1⟺∣x∣<2. So R=2, and at x=±2 every term is 1: interval (−2,2).”
Why: 4n1 is the coefficient of x2n, not of xn: the odd coefficients are 0 and the shortcut compares the wrong numbers. Always apply the test to the terms as written.
Which method to choose
Which test at an endpoint, by the FORM of the series
The ratio test has given ∣x−a∣<R. Substitute x=a−R and x=a+R, write each numerical series in full, and read its form
If the terms do not tend to 0 (they are all plus or minus 1, or they grow like n) → divergence test: the endpoint is excluded in one line
Example: ∑4nnxn at x=4: the terms are n, diverges
If the absolute values behave like np1 with p>1 → absolute convergence by p-series or comparison, which settles BOTH endpoints at once
Example: ∑n25nxn at x=±5: n21, both included
If constant sign, absolute values like np1 with p≤1 → p-series or limit comparison: diverges
Example: ∑n+1(−1)nxn at x=−1: ∑n+11 diverges
If alternating sign, absolute values decreasing to 0 but like np1 with p≤1 → alternating series test: converges, conditionally
Example: ∑n3nxn at x=−3: ∑n(−1)n converges
If the series came from 1−u1 with nothing else done to it → ∣u∣=1 at both endpoints: both excluded, no further test
Example: 1+3x1 at x=±31: terms ±1
If the term is a power n of a base that tends to 1 → form 1∞: compute the limit of the terms with a logarithm before concluding
Example: (1−2n+65)n→e−5/2=0: diverges
Never the ratio or root test at an endpoint: there its limit is 1 by construction, the only value on which it is silent.
How the answer is expected to be written
A marker ticks steps. Here they are in order, with the concluding sentence expected word for word.
Writing an interval of convergence
When to use it: Any question that says find the radius and the interval of convergence
1Name the term an, with x fixed, and apply the ratio test (or the root test) to ∣an∣, with the limit written.
2Solve limit <1 in the form ∣x−a∣<R: state the centre and the radius separately.
3Substitute each endpoint, write the numerical series in full, name its test and verify the hypotheses of that test.
4Conclude with the interval, each bracket justified by the verdict of its endpoint.
Concluding sentence
“By the ratio test the series converges absolutely for ∣x∣<3 and diverges for ∣x∣>3, so R=3. At x=3 it is ∑n1, which diverges; at x=−3 it is ∑n(−1)n, which converges by the alternating series test. The interval of convergence is [−3,3).”
The trap: Writing the two endpoint verdicts without the series they come from: the marker cannot tell which test applies to which series, and gives nothing for a verdict alone.
Marking: Typically 2 marks for the radius with the ratio test written, 1 to 2 marks per endpoint (series written, test named, hypotheses checked), and the interval with the right brackets.
Check before you hand in
Five minutes of checking recover more marks than one more problem started in a hurry.
The centre test
Substitute the centre into the series you built: only its first term survives, and it must equal the value of the function there.
2+x1 at x=0 is 21; a series starting with 1 has lost a factor 21.
The midpoint test
Whatever the brackets, the interval found must have the centre as its midpoint and the radius as its half-length.
∑n(2x−3)n: [1,2) has midpoint 23 and half-length 21, as it should.
The asymptote test
For a rational function built from 1/(1 - u), the radius is the distance from the centre to the nearest point where the function blows up. Use it as a check, not as a proof.
x+51 about a=2: the distance from 2 to −5 is 7, the radius found.
The first-terms test
When a numerical sum is obtained by evaluating a series, add three or four terms by hand: the value must be close.
∑2nn=2: 21+42+83+164=813, and the terms left are small and positive.
The typical problem, taken apart
Interval, closed form and a numerical sum
Let g(x)=∑n=1∞n2n(x−1)n. Find the interval of convergence, a closed form for g, and deduce the sum of ∑n=1∞n2n(−1)n.
No calculator. Every step must be justified as on a MATH 141 final.
Step 1
Ratio test, x fixed: anan+1=2∣x−1∣⋅n+1n→2∣x−1∣, which is <1 iff ∣x−1∣<2. Centre 1, R=2, open interval (−1,3).
Why
The limit written in full is the first mark; the centre and the radius are stated separately because the next two steps use them.
Step 2
At x=3: ∑n2n2n=∑n1, diverges (p=1). At x=−1: ∑n2n(−2)n=∑n(−1)n, alternating with n1 decreasing to 0: converges. Interval [−1,3).
Why
Each endpoint is its own numerical series with its own test; the ratio test gives 1 at both and could decide neither.
Step 3
For ∣x−1∣<2, differentiate term by term: g′(x)=∑n≥12n(x−1)n−1=21⋅1−2x−11=3−x1.
Why
Differentiating removes the n of the denominator and leaves a geometric series with u=2x−1, whose sum is known.
Step 4
Integrate: g(x)=−ln(3−x)+C. At the centre, g(1)=0 (every term contains (x−1)n with n≥1), so 0=−ln2+C, C=ln2 and g(x)=ln3−x2.
Why
The constant is fixed at the centre, where the series is worth its constant term; without it, g(1) would be −ln2, not 0.
Step 5
x=0 lies in [−1,3) and gives (x−1)n=(−1)n: ∑n2n(−1)n=g(0)=ln32. Check: −21+81−241+641≈−0.40, and ln2−ln3≈0.69−1.10=−0.41.
Why
A point is substituted only once it is checked to be inside the interval; the first-terms test then confirms the value.
The conclusion, written out
“The series converges exactly on [−1,3), where g(x)=ln3−x2; hence ∑n=1∞n2n(−1)n=ln32.”
The classic mistake on this problem: Stopping at (−1,3), or writing g(x)=−ln(3−x) without the constant, which gives ∑n2n(−1)n=−ln3: negative, plausible, and wrong, since the first-terms test gives about −0.40, not −1.10.
Learn by heart
•The ratio test gives R, never the interval: at ∣x−a∣=R its limit is 1 and it is silent.
•Each endpoint: write the numerical series, name its test, check its hypotheses.
•1−u1=∑un for ∣u∣<1 only; never at ∣u∣=1.
•Factor to create the 1: 2+x1=21⋅1+x/21, and ∣x∣<2.
•Substituting x2 takes the square root of R; substituting cx divides it by ∣c∣.
•Differentiating and integrating keep R; differentiating may lose an endpoint, integrating may gain one.
•After integrating, find C at the centre. After differentiating, evaluate on the last line only.
•Outside its interval a series is worth nothing, even where the function exists.
Frequently asked questions
How do I find the interval of convergence of a power series?
Apply the ratio test to the absolute value of the general term, with x fixed, and solve limit less than one: this gives the centre and the radius. Then substitute each endpoint into the series and test the two numerical series separately, with the divergence test, a p-series, a comparison or the alternating series test. The interval is written with each bracket decided by its endpoint.
Why can't the ratio test decide the endpoints of a power series?
Because the radius is defined as the place where the ratio limit equals one, and a limit equal to one is exactly the case where the ratio test gives no conclusion. The same holds for the root test. At an endpoint the series becomes an ordinary numerical series, and only the tests that can decide it, such as p-series or the alternating series test, may be used.
Does differentiating a power series change its interval of convergence?
It keeps the radius but not necessarily the endpoints. Differentiating multiplies each term by n, so a series that converged at an endpoint can diverge there after differentiation. Integrating divides by n plus one and can only gain an endpoint. The series of x to the n over n converges at minus one, its derivative does not.
How do I write 1 over (a + x) as a power series?
Factor a out of the denominator to create the form one over one minus u: one over (a plus x) equals one over a, times one over (1 plus x over a). Then u is minus x over a, the series is the geometric series in u multiplied by one over a, and it converges when the absolute value of x is less than the absolute value of a. Check at x equal to zero: the series must give one over a.
Practise it
Corrected exercises: Power series, MATH 141 at McGill
A method is proved on a paper, not on a sheet. The set for the same chapter takes each of these traps into a problem, with the solution written out step by step.
Something missing from this sheet?A method, a trap, an exercise to practise it, a mistake you spotted: tell me, I read every request.
Sending goes through your free space: that is how I can answer you and tell you when the exercise is added. An email is enough, no password. Create your space.
Rather not create an account? Write to me directly.
Get in touch for a first session. Power series are where every test of the series chapters is used at once, and where the endpoint marks are won or lost.