Answers
- a) dxdy=x−2y3x2−y; at P: slope 1, tangent y=x−3, normal y=−x−1; at Q: slope 0, tangent y=3
- b) Only R(2,1): x=2y gives 8y3−y2−7=(y−1)(8y2+7y+7)=0
- c) y=3x2 gives (x−1)(9x3+7x2+7x+7)=0: the point Q, and a root of the cubic in (−0.9,−0.8), about −0.888
- d) y′′(P)=56
a) At P: 1−(1)(−2)+4=7. At Q: 1−3+9=7. At R: 8−2+1=7. All three lie on C. Differentiate both sides with respect to x, y being a function of x: x3 gives 3x2; xy is a PRODUCT and gives y+xy′; y2 gives 2yy′ (chain rule, inner function y). So 3x2−y−xy′+2yy′=0. Collect the y′ terms, factor y′ out, and divide: y′(2y−x)=y−3x2, so dxdy=x−2y3x2−y wherever x=2y. The sign is where the marks go: −xy gives two negative terms, −y−xy′, not one.
At P(1,−2): y′=1+43+2=1, and the tangent is y=−2+(x−1)=x−3. The normal at P has slope −1: y=−2−(x−1)=−x−1. At Q(1,3): y′=1−63−3=0, and the tangent is the horizontal line y=3, the top of the upper arc on the figure.
b) A vertical tangent needs the denominator x−2y=0 with the numerator not zero. The condition x=2y describes a line, not the answer: the answer is where that line meets C. Substitute x=2y: 8y3−2y2+y2=7, that is 8y3−y2−7=0. The coefficients add up to 0, so y=1 is a root, and dividing by y−1 gives 8y3−y2−7=(y−1)(8y2+7y+7). The quadratic has discriminant 49−224=−175<0: no other root. So y=1, x=2, the point R(2,1), where the numerator is 12−1=11=0: the tangent there is indeed vertical. R is the rightmost point of the curve.
c) A horizontal tangent needs 3x2−y=0 with x−2y=0. Substitute y=3x2: x3−3x3+9x4=7, that is 9x4−2x3−7=0. Again the coefficients add up to 0, so x=1 is a root and 9x4−2x3−7=(x−1)(9x3+7x2+7x+7). The root x=1 gives y=3, the point Q of a), where x−2y=−5=0.
The cubic k(x)=9x3+7x2+7x+7 is a polynomial, hence continuous on [−1,−0.8], with k(−1)=−9+7−7+7=−2<0 and k(−0.8)=−4.608+4.48−5.6+7=1.272>0. By the Intermediate Value Theorem, k has a root x0 in (−1,−0.8), and (x0,3x02) is a point of C with a horizontal tangent, since there x0−6x02<0 is not zero. Bisection: k(−0.9)=−6.561+5.67−6.3+7=−0.191<0, so the root lies in (−0.9,−0.8). It is about −0.888, and the point about (−0.888,2.366): the bottom of the dip of the upper arc. The algebra, not the calculus, found both points: substitute, then factor by the obvious root.
d) Differentiate 3x2−y−xy′+2yy′=0 once more, y and y′ being functions of x: the product xy′ gives y′+xy′′ and the product yy′ gives (y′)2+yy′′, so 6x−y′−y′−xy′′+2(y′)2+2yy′′=0. Substitute the numbers BEFORE isolating y′′: at P, x=1, y=−2, y′=1, so 6−1−1−y′′+2−4y′′=0, that is 6=5y′′ and y′′(P)=56. Differentiating the formula x−2y3x2−y with the quotient rule works too, provided y is still treated as a function of x inside it.