PHYS 101 Introductory Physics, Mechanics • McGill University, Montreal

Revision sheet: friction, circular motion and gravitation (PHYS 101)

This sheet is not a summary of the chapter: you already have the lecture notes. It answers one question, what makes students lose marks on friction, circular motion and gravitation in PHYS 101 at McGill University, and what exact line to write instead. Everything here is algebra, proportions and right-angle trigonometry, with no derivative and no integral anywhere, because that is the course PHYS 101 actually is.

Two reversals carry the whole chapter, and almost every trap below is one of them in a new costume. Static friction is an inequality, not a formula: it takes whatever value keeps the object still, and μsN\mu_{s}N is only the largest value it may take. The centripetal force is not a force: it is the name of the resultant, along the radius, of the real forces already drawn. Get those two straight and the banked curve taken too slowly, the bucket of water, the centrifuge, the spinning space habitat and the orbiting satellite all become the same three lines of work.

Mark this sheet as read or add it to your favourites: a free account, no password, keeps your read sheets and favourites from one visit to the next, tells you which chapter to tackle next and lets you ask for the method or exercise you are missing. Create your space, an email is enough.

The thread of the chapter

The centripetal force is not one more arrow to add to your diagram, it is the NAME of the resultant of the arrows already on it. Static friction works the same way: it has no value of its own, it takes whatever value stops the sliding, and μsN\mu_{s}N is only the ceiling it may not pass.

This chapter is part of PHYS 101, Introductory Physics - Mechanics (McGill)

Before this chapter, you need

The essentials

On your formula sheet: this chapter's lines, and when each one holds

  • • Ffr,k=μkFNF_{fr,k}=\mu_{k}F_{N}: Only while the surfaces slide on each other. FNF_{N} comes from the free-body diagram: it is not mgmg on a slope or under a slanted pull.
  • • Ffr,s≤μsFNF_{fr,s}\le\mu_{s}F_{N}: An inequality: static friction takes whatever value keeps the object at rest, up to μsFN\mu_{s}F_{N}. The equality holds only at the point of slipping.
  • • v=ωrv=\omega r: ω\omega in rad/s, never in rpm: multiply revolutions per minute by 2π60\frac{2\pi}{60}.
  • • a=v2ra=\frac{v^{2}}{r}: Directed toward the centre. It is not a force: on the diagram, the real forces (tension, normal, friction, gravity) supply mv2r\frac{mv^{2}}{r} between them.
  • • tan⁡θ=v2rg\tan\theta=\frac{v^{2}}{rg}: Only at the design speed of a frictionless bank. Slower, friction acts up the slope; faster, down the slope.
  • • F=Gm1m2r2F=\frac{Gm_{1}m_{2}}{r^{2}}: rr is measured between CENTRES: the radius of the planet plus the altitude, never the altitude alone.
  • • G=6.67×10−11G=6.67\times10^{-11}: In N m²/kg². At a planet's surface GM=gR2GM=gR^{2}, which avoids looking up the planet's mass.
  • • T2r3=4π2GM\frac{T^{2}}{r^{3}}=\frac{4\pi^{2}}{GM}: A circular orbit around a central mass MM, the mass at the CENTRE, not the satellite's. Two satellites of the same body share the same T2r3\frac{T^{2}}{r^{3}}.

The sheet prints each equation, never the condition under which it holds: copy the condition next to its line on your own sheet before the exam. This sheet writes fkf_{k}, fsf_{s} and NN where the formula sheet writes Ffr,kF_{fr,k}, Ffr,sF_{fr,s} and FNF_{N}: same forces.

Static friction is an inequality, kinetic friction is a value

  • • At rest: fsf_{s} takes whatever value balances the other forces along the surface, and it obeys fs≤μsNf_{s} \le \mu_{s}N.
  • • On the point of slipping, and only there: fs=μsNf_{s} = \mu_{s}N. The words that announce it are on the point of, about to, minimum, maximum.
  • • Sliding: fk=μkNf_{k} = \mu_{k}N, directed against the motion, no longer adjustable, and μk<μs\mu_{k} < \mu_{s} for the same pair of surfaces.
  • • The test that opens every friction problem: compare the force demanded along the surface with μsN\mu_{s}N, then choose which of the two lines above to write.
  • • NN is not always mgmg. On an incline N=mgcos⁡θN = mg\cos\theta; on a banked curve at its design speed N=mgcos⁡θN = \frac{mg}{\cos\theta}; in a lift N=m(g±a)N = m(g \pm a).
2040608010012014016020406080100120140f = Fceiling 110.25 Nkinetic 78.4 Nforce applied along the surface (N)friction f (N)
Friction rises along the line f=Ff = F as long as the block holds, reaches 110.25110.25 N, then DROPS to 78.478.4 N the moment it slides: the block leaps forward with no extra push.

A single number, μsN\mu_{s}N, plays two different parts: it is a CEILING when the object is at rest and a VALUE only at the instant it lets go. Half the marks lost on friction come from treating the ceiling as a value.

Friction on the diagram: the two standard cases

  • • Friction lies ALONG the surface and the normal force perpendicular to it; both come from the same contact, and on a free-body diagram both start at the centre of the body.
  • • It opposes the sliding, or, for a body at rest, the sliding that would happen without it: on an incline at rest, fsf_{s} points UP the slope.
  • • Pulled at constant speed on a level floor: T=fk=μkmgT = f_{k} = \mu_{k}mg. At rest on an incline: fs=mgsin⁡θf_{s} = mg\sin\theta, as long as that stays under μsmgcos⁡θ\mu_{s}mg\cos\theta.
N = 98 Nmg = 98 NT = 29.4 Nfk = 29.4 Nv constant25°mgNfs
Left, 1010 kg pulled at constant speed: the pull matches fk=29.4f_{k} = 29.4 N. Right, 4.04.0 kg at rest at 25∘25^{\circ}: fs=mgsin⁡25∘=16.6f_{s} = mg\sin 25^{\circ} = 16.6 N points up the slope.

A block sliding UP an incline has friction pointing DOWN the slope, adding to mgsin⁡θmg\sin\theta: always ask which way the surface is rubbing.

Centripetal is a direction, never a new force

  • • ac=v2r=4π2rT2a_{c} = \frac{v^{2}}{r} = \frac{4\pi^{2}r}{T^{2}}, always pointing at the centre of the circle.
  • • The method, unchanged from chapter 4: draw the real forces, point one axis at the centre, write ∑Fradius=mv2r\sum F_{\text{radius}} = \frac{mv^{2}}{r}.
  • • The other axis carries NO acceleration in a horizontal circle: on it, ∑F=0\sum F = 0 as in any statics problem.
  • • Uniform means constant SPEED. The velocity changes direction at every instant, and that is the whole reason there is an acceleration.
  • • Nothing on a correct free-body diagram is labelled FcF_{c}, and nothing points away from the centre.
centrevavava
Uniform circular motion seen from above: the velocity is tangent and keeps the same length, the acceleration always points at the centre, and the two are perpendicular at every point.

Use 4π2rT2\frac{4\pi^{2}r}{T^{2}} whenever the data are a period or a rotation rate, and v2r\frac{v^{2}}{r} only when a speed is given. The two forms hold different things fixed, and picking the wrong one turns a doubling into a halving.

Banked curve and conical pendulum: one diagram

  • • Axes horizontal and vertical, NOT along the road: the acceleration is horizontal and points at the centre of the turn.
  • • Banked curve without friction: Ncos⁡θ=mgN\cos\theta = mg vertically and Nsin⁡θ=mv2rN\sin\theta = \frac{mv^{2}}{r} horizontally, so tan⁡θ=v2rg\tan\theta = \frac{v^{2}}{rg}, with no mass left in it.
  • • Conical pendulum: the same two equations with TT in place of NN, Tcos⁡θ=mgT\cos\theta = mg and Tsin⁡θ=mv2rT\sin\theta = \frac{mv^{2}}{r}, θ\theta measured from the vertical.
  • • Below the design speed the bank pushes inward too hard and static friction points UP the slope, f=m(gsin⁡θ−v2rcos⁡θ)f = m\left(g\sin\theta - \frac{v^{2}}{r}\cos\theta\right); above it, DOWN. The formula sheet's tan⁡θ=v2rg\tan\theta = \frac{v^{2}}{rg} is the frictionless line only.
N sin θNmgcentreT sin θTmg
Left, a car on a 12∘12^{\circ} bank, to scale: Ncos⁡θN\cos\theta holds the weight, Nsin⁡θN\sin\theta turns the car. Right, the conical pendulum, where the string plays the part of the road.

On a frictionless banked curve N=mgcos⁡θN = \frac{mg}{\cos\theta} is LARGER than mgmg, the reverse of an incline. Writing mgcos⁡θmg\cos\theta there is the classic slip.

Vertical circles: the crest, the dip and the loop

  • • Point one axis at the centre of the circle and write ΣFtoward centre=mv2r\Sigma F_{\text{toward centre}} = \frac{mv^{2}}{r} with the real forces only.
  • • Over a crest the centre is below: mg−N=mv2rmg - N = \frac{mv^{2}}{r}, and NN drops to zero at v=grv = \sqrt{gr}. In a dip the centre is above: N−mg=mv2rN - mg = \frac{mv^{2}}{r}, and the seat presses harder.
  • • At the top of a loop the track is above the car, so NN and mgmg BOTH point at the centre: N+mg=mv2rN + mg = \frac{mv^{2}}{r}, and the slowest safe speed is again gr\sqrt{gr}.
mgNaover a crestmgNain a dipmgNatop of a loop
Forces to scale, with v2r=g2\frac{v^{2}}{r} = \frac{g}{2} on the crest and in the dip and 3g2\frac{3g}{2} at the top of the loop: aa always points at the centre, and NN completes it.

The apparent weight is NN in all three cases: a pilot pulling out of a dive feels heavy, a car cresting a hill feels light.

Gravitation: three formulas and one distance

  • • F=Gm1m2r2F = G\frac{m_{1}m_{2}}{r^{2}} with G=6.67×10−11G = 6.67\times 10^{-11} N m2^2/kg2^2, and rr measured CENTRE to centre.
  • • At the surface of a body of mass MM and radius RR: g=GMR2g = \frac{GM}{R^{2}}. Mass is in kilograms everywhere, weight is a force in newtons.
  • • Circular orbit: v=GMrv = \sqrt{\frac{GM}{r}} and T2=4π2GMr3T^{2} = \frac{4\pi^{2}}{GM}r^{3}. The orbiting mass cancels out of both.
  • • Inverse SQUARE: distance ×2\times 2 divides the force by 44, distance ×3\times 3 divides it by 99. To halve gg you go out by 2\sqrt{2}.
  • • Apparent weight is the NORMAL force: N=m(g±v2r)N = m\left(g \pm \frac{v^{2}}{r}\right), plus at the bottom of a dip, minus at the top of a crest.
EarthF on satelliteF on Earthvr, centre to centre
Not to scale: the Earth pulls the satellite and the satellite pulls the Earth with the same GMmr2G\frac{Mm}{r^{2}}, a third-law pair on two bodies; rr runs centre to centre.

Orbital speed DROPS as you climb, since v∝1/rv \propto 1/\sqrt{r}: the geostationary satellite moves at 3.13.1 km/s against 7.77.7 km/s for the space station. Any result of yours that still contains the satellite mass has an algebra error in it.

Artificial gravity: the floor supplies the circle

  • • On a ring of radius RR spinning at ω\omega, the floor is the only force on anything resting on it, and it points at the axis: N=mω2RN = m\omega^{2}R. No gravity is involved.
  • • Earth-like load on the rim: ω2R=g\omega^{2}R = g, so ω=g/R\omega = \sqrt{g/R}. For R=224R = 224 m, ω=0.209\omega = 0.209 rad/s, one turn in 3030 s.
  • • On a deck at distance rr from the axis, turning with the same ω\omega: N=mω2r=mg rRN = m\omega^{2}r = mg\,\frac{r}{R}. A deck at 0.60 R0.60\,R gives 0.60 g0.60\,g, and on the axis there is no load at all.
  • • At fixed ω\omega use a=ω2ra = \omega^{2}r, which grows with rr. The form v2r\frac{v^{2}}{r} falls with rr only at fixed speed, which a rigid habitat does not have.
axisNaNa
Forces to scale: the floor pushes each crate toward the axis, with N=mgN = mg on the main deck and N=0.60 mgN = 0.60\,mg on the deck at 0.60 R0.60\,R; NN and aa always point at the axis.

What feels like weight on the rim is the floor pushing you INWARD. Nothing presses you outward: without the floor you would carry on in a straight line, along a tangent.

The rules in table form

Each row reads from left to right: the assumptions, then the result. A red cell is not an answer, it is the finding that the form settles nothing and the instruction to rewrite it. Every case is followed by a worked example.

Which friction force to write, for a crate of 2525 kg on level ground

Take μs=0.45\mu_{s} = 0.45 and μk=0.32\mu_{k} = 0.32, so N=245N = 245 N, the ceiling is μsN=110.25\mu_{s}N = 110.25 N and the sliding value is μkN=78.4\mu_{k}N = 78.4 N. Read the line that matches what the crate is DOING, never the line that matches the word friction.

What the crate doesWhat decides the valueThe friction force
at rest, pushed below the ceiling Newton's first law along the surface fs=Ff_{s} = F

Example: Pushed with F=60F = 60 N: fs=60f_{s} = 60 N and a=0a = 0, because 60<110.2560 < 110.25.

at rest, on the point of slipping the ceiling is exactly reached fs=μsN=110.25f_{s} = \mu_{s}N = 110.25 N

Example: The largest push the crate takes without moving is 0.45×245=110.250.45 \times 245 = 110.25 N.

sliding friction has locked at its kinetic value fk=μkN=78.4f_{k} = \mu_{k}N = 78.4 N

Example: Pushed with F=130F = 130 N: a=130−78.425=2.06a = \frac{130 - 78.4}{25} = 2.06 m/s2^2.

at rest, and you write f=μsNf = \mu_{s}N anyway nothing, the equality is not available yet no value rule that does not exist

Example: Writing 110.25110.25 N under a push of 6060 N leaves a net force of −50.25-50.25 N on a crate that is standing perfectly still.

Same form, other result: Under F=60F = 60 N the friction is 6060 N; under F=110F = 110 N it is 110110 N. Same ceiling of 110.25110.25 N, two different friction forces, so the ceiling cannot be the answer.

What to do: Run the comparison first: is the demanded force below μsN\mu_{s}N or above it? Then write fs=Ff_{s} = F or fk=μkNf_{k} = \mu_{k}N.

The same three lines govern a block on an incline, with N=mgcos⁡θN = mg\cos\theta in place of mgmg, and a coin on a turntable, where the demanded force is mv2r\frac{mv^{2}}{r} instead of a push.

The mistakes that cost marks

These are the errors I correct most often in session. Each one costs marks on a paper, even when the reasoning behind it is right.

1. Static friction set equal to its ceiling on a block that is merely at rest

2 to 4 points, and every later number of the problem inherits the wrong friction

What not to write

The crate does not move, so fs=μsN=0.45×245=110.25f_{s} = \mu_{s}N = 0.45 \times 245 = 110.25 N.

What to write

The crate does not move, so the forces along the floor cancel: fs=F=60f_{s} = F = 60 N. The ceiling μsN=110.25\mu_{s}N = 110.25 N is not reached.

Why: fs≤μsNf_{s} \le \mu_{s}N is an INEQUALITY. The equality holds at one single instant, the one where the block lets go, and the question says so in words: on the point of, about to slide, minimum force.

2. An invented centripetal arrow added to a diagram that was already complete

the whole question, because the diagram now balances and predicts a straight line

What not to write

The car is turning, so the forces on it are the weight, the normal force, friction and the centripetal force Fc=mv2rF_{c} = \frac{mv^{2}}{r}.

What to write

The forces on it are the weight, the normal force and friction. Their resultant along the radius IS the centripetal force, and it equals mv2r\frac{mv^{2}}{r}.

NmgfcorrectNmgfFcwrongcentre
Seen from behind, centre to the left. Correct: three real forces, friction already supplying mv2r\frac{mv^{2}}{r}. Wrong: the black Fc is that same force drawn twice.

Why: A force is something another object exerts. Circular motion supplies no new object, so it supplies no new force. Writing FcF_{c} as a fourth arrow counts friction twice, and the sum along the radius comes out zero when it should be mv2r\frac{mv^{2}}{r}.

3. The incline formula for the normal force carried over to a banked curve

3 points, and the error is visible without a calculator

What not to write

On the banked curve, N=mgcos⁡12∘=1200×9.8×0.978=11 500N = mg\cos 12^{\circ} = 1200 \times 9.8 \times 0.978 = 11\,500 N.

What to write

At the design speed no friction is needed and the car has no vertical acceleration, so Ncos⁡12∘=mgN\cos 12^{\circ} = mg and N=mgcos⁡12∘=12 023N = \frac{mg}{\cos 12^{\circ}} = 12\,023 N, LARGER than the weight.

Why: On an incline the block accelerates ALONG the surface, so the axes follow the surface and the weight is split. On a banked curve the acceleration is HORIZONTAL, so the axes stay horizontal and vertical and the NORMAL force is split. The road holds the car up and turns it at the same time, so it must push harder than the weight.

4. A larger radius read as a smaller acceleration

2 points, and a conclusion that is exactly the reverse of what happens

What not to write

Since ac=v2ra_{c} = \frac{v^{2}}{r}, the coin further from the axis of the turntable has the smaller acceleration and is the safer one.

What to write

The turntable rate is fixed, so use ac=4π2rT2a_{c} = \frac{4\pi^{2}r}{T^{2}}: doubling rr from 0.120.12 m to 0.240.24 m DOUBLES aca_{c}, from 2.662.66 to 5.335.33 m/s2^2.

Why: v2r\frac{v^{2}}{r} falls with rr only at constant SPEED. On a turntable the speed is not constant between the two positions, the period is: the outer coin travels twice as far in the same time. Ask what the problem holds fixed before choosing the form.

5. An altitude fed into the law of gravitation in place of a distance from the centre

the whole question, for an answer out by a factor of about 290290

What not to write

At 400400 km above the ground, g=GM(4×105)2=2.5×103g = \frac{GM}{(4\times 10^{5})^{2}} = 2.5\times 10^{3} m/s2^2.

What to write

r=RE+h=6.37×106+4.00×105=6.77×106r = R_{E} + h = 6.37\times 10^{6} + 4.00\times 10^{5} = 6.77\times 10^{6} m, so g=3.982×1014(6.77×106)2=8.69g = \frac{3.982\times 10^{14}}{(6.77\times 10^{6})^{2}} = 8.69 m/s2^2.

Why: In F=Gm1m2r2F = G\frac{m_{1}m_{2}}{r^{2}}, rr is the separation of the two CENTRES. Add the radius of the planet to the altitude every time, and run the order-of-magnitude check: no gravitational field near a planet is thousands of times stronger than at its surface.

6. Weightlessness in orbit blamed on an absence of gravity

2 points on a conceptual question that turns up on almost every final

What not to write

Astronauts float inside the station because there is no gravity 400400 km above the ground.

What to write

There gg is still 8.698.69 m/s2^2, 8989 per cent of its value at the ground, and it is what holds the station in orbit. They float because the station and everything in it fall together, so nothing presses on the floor: N=0N = 0.

Why: What your body feels is never gg, it is the NORMAL force. It is larger than mgmg at the bottom of a dive, smaller at the top of a crest, and zero in free fall, while gg barely changes in any of those situations.

7. A square root taken where Kepler's third law asks for a cube root

3 points, although the order of magnitude catches it at once

What not to write

From T2=4π2GMr3T^{2} = \frac{4\pi^{2}}{GM}r^{3}, a 2424 h period gives r=GM T24π2=2.7×1011r = \sqrt{\frac{GM\,T^{2}}{4\pi^{2}}} = 2.7\times 10^{11} m.

What to write

r=(GM T24π2)1/3=4.22×107r = \left(\frac{GM\,T^{2}}{4\pi^{2}}\right)^{1/3} = 4.22\times 10^{7} m, which is an altitude of about 35 90035\,900 km.

Why: The law is cubic in rr and quadratic in TT, so isolating rr needs a cube root. The check costs one second: a satellite of the Earth cannot orbit at 2.7×10112.7\times 10^{11} m, which is about 700700 times the distance to the Moon.

8. An outward force invented to keep the water in the bucket

2 points here, and the same mistake ruins the centrifuge and the orbit questions

What not to write

At the top of the swing the centrifugal force is larger than the weight, which is what keeps the water in the bucket.

What to write

At the top, tension and weight BOTH point down, toward the centre: T+mg=mv2LT + mg = \frac{mv^{2}}{L}. The water stays in as long as v≥gL=3.28v \ge \sqrt{gL} = 3.28 m/s with L=1.10L = 1.10 m.

aaTmgtopTmgbottom
At the top both arrows point at the centre and ADD, so the rope can go slack; at the bottom they OPPOSE, so the rope carries more than the weight. Same rope, same bucket, two different equations.

Why: No object exerts an outward force on the water. The bucket bottom is ABOVE the water at the top of the circle and can only push it downward. That push plus the weight is exactly what the circle demands, and at vmin⁡v_{\min} the push is zero and gravity does all of it.

9. Friction on a banked curve pointed toward the centre when the car is too slow

3 points, because the sign of ff carries into NN and into μs\mu_{s}

What not to write

The car takes the icy ramp at 9.09.0 m/s, below its design speed, so friction points down the slope and helps it turn.

What to write

Below the design speed the bank alone pushes inward too hard, so friction points UP the slope: f=m(gsin⁡θ−v2rcos⁡θ)=1.33×103f = m\left(g\sin\theta - \frac{v^{2}}{r}\cos\theta\right) = 1.33\times 10^{3} N, which needs μs≥0.113\mu_{s} \ge 0.113.

mgNfaslower: 9.0 m/smgNadesign: 13.3 m/smgNfafaster: 17 m/scentre
Same ramp, forces to scale except friction, drawn three times longer: below the design speed ff points up the slope, at it f=0f = 0, above it down the slope; aa always points at the centre.

Why: Friction opposes the sliding that would happen without it. Slower than the design speed, the car would slide DOWN the bank, toward the inside; faster, UP and out. Check the two limits: at v=0v = 0 it is a car parked on an incline, f=mgsin⁡θf = mg\sin\theta up the slope, and at the design speed f=0f = 0.

Which method to choose

Which friction expression to write

Decide on what the problem says about MOTION along the surface, never on the word friction.

  • If the object is at rest and stays at rest → fsf_{s} is whatever balances the other forces along the surface, then check fs≤μsNf_{s} \le \mu_{s}N

    Example: pushed with 6060 N on a level floor: fs=60f_{s} = 60 N, ceiling 110.25110.25 N, so it holds

    the single most profitable line of the chapter, and the one most often skipped

  • If the words on the point of, about to move, minimum or maximum appear → fs=μsNf_{s} = \mu_{s}N, the one situation where the equality holds

    Example: tilting a plank until the block lets go: tan⁡θs=μs=0.60\tan\theta_{s} = \mu_{s} = 0.60, so θs=31.0∘\theta_{s} = 31.0^{\circ}

    this is also how μs\mu_{s} is measured in the laboratory, and the angle does not depend on the mass

  • If the object is already sliding → fk=μkNf_{k} = \mu_{k}N, directed against the motion

    Example: 0.32×245=78.40.32 \times 245 = 78.4 N, so a push of 130130 N gives a=2.06a = 2.06 m/s2^2

    friction stops adjusting here, which is why the block leaps forward at the moment it lets go

  • If the object turns without sliding on the surface that carries it → static friction again, and it IS the centripetal force: mv2r≤μsN\frac{mv^{2}}{r} \le \mu_{s}N

    Example: coin on a turntable, ac=2.66a_{c} = 2.66 m/s2^2, so μs≥0.272\mu_{s} \ge 0.272

    the mass cancels, so a heavy car and a light car leave the road at the same speed

On an incline replace N=mgN = mg by N=mgcos⁡θN = mg\cos\theta before anything else. Forgetting the cosine multiplies both the ceiling and the kinetic value by the same wrong factor, so the error survives to the end of the problem undetected.

Which circular-motion equation to write

The equation is always ∑F=mv2r\sum F = \frac{mv^{2}}{r} along the radius. What changes is which forces sit on that radius, and that is decided by WHERE the centre is.

  • If flat curve, centre horizontal, friction the only horizontal force → mv2r≤μsmg\frac{mv^{2}}{r} \le \mu_{s}mg, so vmax⁡=μsgrv_{\max} = \sqrt{\mu_{s}gr}

    Example: r=60r = 60 m on dry asphalt, μs=0.70\mu_{s} = 0.70: vmax⁡=20.3v_{\max} = 20.3 m/s, about 7373 km/h

    no mass in the answer, so the loaded truck and the small car go off at the same speed

  • If banked curve or conical pendulum, one tilted force and no friction → Xcos⁡θ=mgX\cos\theta = mg and Xsin⁡θ=mv2rX\sin\theta = \frac{mv^{2}}{r}, divide to get tan⁡θ=v2rg\tan\theta = \frac{v^{2}}{rg}

    Example: θ=12∘\theta = 12^{\circ} and r=85r = 85 m give v=13.3v = 13.3 m/s, about 47.947.9 km/h

    XX is the normal force for the car and the tension for the pendulum; in both, X>mgX > mg

  • If top of a vertical circle, the centre is BELOW → T+mg=mv2rT + mg = \frac{mv^{2}}{r}, and T=0T = 0 gives vmin⁡=grv_{\min} = \sqrt{gr}

    Example: L=1.10L = 1.10 m: vmin⁡=3.28v_{\min} = 3.28 m/s, below which the rope goes slack

    the same condition, v=grv = \sqrt{gr}, is apparent weightlessness at the crest of a hill

  • If bottom of a vertical circle, of a dip or of a dive, the centre is ABOVE → N−mg=mv2rN - mg = \frac{mv^{2}}{r}, so N=m(g+v2r)N = m\left(g + \frac{v^{2}}{r}\right)

    Example: 180180 m/s on a 650650 m arc: Nmg=1+v2rg=6.09\frac{N}{mg} = 1 + \frac{v^{2}}{rg} = 6.09

    this is where ropes break and pilots grey out, never at the top

  • If orbit, gravity the only force → GMmr2=mv2rG\frac{Mm}{r^{2}} = \frac{mv^{2}}{r}, so v=GMrv = \sqrt{\frac{GM}{r}} and T2=4π2GMr3T^{2} = \frac{4\pi^{2}}{GM}r^{3}

    Example: r=6.77×106r = 6.77\times 10^{6} m gives v=7.67v = 7.67 km/s and T=92.4T = 92.4 min

    the orbiting mass cancels in the first line, so it must be absent from every answer

Draw the centre of the circle on your sketch before writing anything. Four of these five branches are told apart by that single dot, and the two vertical-circle cases differ only by which side of the object it sits on.

How the answer is expected to be written

A marker ticks steps. Here they are in order, with the concluding sentence expected word for word.

Writing up a friction problem

When to use it: Any problem naming a coefficient of friction, on level ground or on an incline.

  1. 1 Draw the free-body diagram and name the surface: friction acts along it, the normal force across it.
  2. 2 Compute NN FIRST and write the line: N=mgN = mg on level ground, N=mgcos⁡θN = mg\cos\theta on an incline. Both coefficients multiply it.
  3. 3 Compute the ceiling μsN\mu_{s}N and compare it with the force demanded along the surface. Write the comparison as a sentence, it is worth a mark on its own.
  4. 4 Choose the branch: at rest, fsf_{s} equals the demanded force; sliding, fk=μkNf_{k} = \mu_{k}N against the motion.
  5. 5 Apply ∑F=ma\sum F = ma along the surface and check that the sign of aa matches the direction you expected.

Concluding sentence

Since F=60F = 60 N is below the ceiling μsN=110.25\mu_{s}N = 110.25 N, the crate stays at rest and the friction force on it is fs=60f_{s} = 60 N.

The trap: The step everybody drops is the third. Without the written comparison, the marker cannot tell whether you chose the right branch or guessed it, and a correct final number in a problem where the block slides earns partial credit at best.

Marking: 1 point for the diagram and NN, 1 point for the ceiling and the comparison, 2 points for the correct branch, 1 point for Newton's second law and the sign.

Writing up a circular motion problem

When to use it: Anything moving on a circle: a curve, a pendulum tracing a cone, a bucket, a centrifuge, a satellite.

  1. 1 Draw ONLY the real forces. If you cannot name the object exerting an arrow, that arrow does not exist.
  2. 2 Mark the centre of the circle on the sketch and draw the axis from the object toward it.
  3. 3 Write ∑Fradius=mv2r\sum F_{\text{radius}} = \frac{mv^{2}}{r}, counting each force positive toward the centre and negative away from it.
  4. 4 Write the second equation on the other axis, where the acceleration is ZERO in a horizontal circle.
  5. 5 Solve, then check that the mass has cancelled everywhere it should, and that any normal force or tension you found is positive.

Concluding sentence

Taking the direction of the centre as positive, the resultant of the real forces along the radius is T+mg=mv2LT + mg = \frac{mv^{2}}{L}, which gives T=25.8T = 25.8 N.

The trap: The sacrificed step is the second. Without the centre drawn, the top and the bottom of a vertical circle get the same equation, and the two differ only by the sign of mgmg: writing T−mgT - mg at the top turns a tension of 25.825.8 N into one of 84.684.6 N.

Marking: 1 point for a diagram with no invented force, 1 point for the axis and the centre, 2 points for the radial equation with its signs, 1 point for the second axis.

Check before you hand in

Five minutes of checking recover more marks than one more problem started in a hurry.

The typical problem, taken apart

The curve at 73 km/h, and what banking actually buys you

A flat curve of radius r=60r = 60 m is covered in dry asphalt, μs=0.70\mu_{s} = 0.70. A car of mass 13001300 kg takes it.

Find the largest speed at which the car holds the curve, and say whether that speed depends on the mass of the car.

Then compare with the same curve banked at 15∘15^{\circ}, first on dry asphalt and then in freezing rain, where μs\mu_{s} falls to 0.100.10.

Or = 60 mv
Seen from above, the centre of the turn is level with the car and the only horizontal force available is friction: the whole problem is fs=mv2rf_{s} = \frac{mv^{2}}{r} with fsf_{s} under its ceiling.

Step 1

Forces on the car: the weight mgmg down, the normal force NN up, friction fsf_{s} horizontal. Nothing else.

Why

Naming the three real forces and stopping there is the step being marked. The car is turning, so a fourth arrow is tempting, and it would be the same friction counted twice.

Step 2

Vertical axis, no acceleration: N=mg=1300×9.8=12 740N = mg = 1300 \times 9.8 = 12\,740 N.

Why

The curve is FLAT, so the car goes neither up nor down and the vertical equation is a statics equation. This is also the line that feeds the friction ceiling, so it comes first.

Step 3

Radial axis, pointing at the centre: fs=mv2rf_{s} = \frac{mv^{2}}{r}, with the constraint fs≤μsN=0.70×12 740=8918f_{s} \le \mu_{s}N = 0.70 \times 12\,740 = 8918 N.

Why

Here is the whole chapter in one line. Friction is not given a value, it is told what it must supply, and separately told what it may not exceed. The inequality is what produces a maximum speed at all.

Step 4

Combine: mv2r≤μsmg\frac{mv^{2}}{r} \le \mu_{s}mg, the mass cancels, vmax⁡=μsgr=0.70×9.8×60=411.6=20.3v_{\max} = \sqrt{\mu_{s}gr} = \sqrt{0.70 \times 9.8 \times 60} = \sqrt{411.6} = 20.3 m/s, that is 73.073.0 km/h.

Why

The mass cancels because it sits on both sides, in the demand mv2r\frac{mv^{2}}{r} and in the supply μsmg\mu_{s}mg. That is why a heavier vehicle is no safer on a curve, which is the answer to the second question and is worth stating in words.

Step 5

Banked at 15∘15^{\circ} with no help from friction: tan⁡15∘=v2rg\tan 15^{\circ} = \frac{v^{2}}{rg}, so v=60×9.8×0.2679=12.6v = \sqrt{60 \times 9.8 \times 0.2679} = 12.6 m/s, about 45.245.2 km/h.

Why

A different mechanism, same three lines: split NN instead of splitting nothing, and divide the two equations. Note that the axes are horizontal and vertical again, NOT along the road surface.

Step 6

In freezing rain, μs=0.10\mu_{s} = 0.10: flat, vmax⁡=0.10×9.8×60=7.7v_{\max} = \sqrt{0.10 \times 9.8 \times 60} = 7.7 m/s, about 27.627.6 km/h. Banked, the design speed 45.245.2 km/h needs no friction at all.

Why

This is why curves are banked. On dry asphalt friction alone already gives 7373 km/h, more than the bank provides; the bank earns its keep the day friction disappears, where it turns 2828 km/h into 4545 km/h with nothing gripping.

The conclusion, written out

On dry asphalt the car holds the flat curve up to 20.320.3 m/s, that is 73.073.0 km/h, whatever its mass; banking the same curve at 15∘15^{\circ} gives a design speed of 12.612.6 m/s, that is 45.245.2 km/h, which still works when the road ices over and the flat curve is down to 27.627.6 km/h.

The classic mistake on this problem: The classic loss is to add the two effects by writing vmax⁡=μsgr+rgtan⁡θv_{\max} = \sqrt{\mu_{s}gr} + \sqrt{rg\tan\theta}. Speeds do not add like that. A banked curve WITH friction is a single free-body diagram in which NN and fsf_{s} both have horizontal components, and it is solved with the same two axes, never by adding two separate answers.

Learn by heart

  • • fs≤μsNf_{s} \le \mu_{s}N is an INEQUALITY; fk=μkNf_{k} = \mu_{k}N is an equality. The equality for fsf_{s} holds only on the point of slipping.
  • • A block lets go of an incline at tan⁡θs=μs\tan\theta_{s} = \mu_{s}, an angle that does not contain the mass.
  • • ac=v2r=4π2rT2a_{c} = \frac{v^{2}}{r} = \frac{4\pi^{2}r}{T^{2}}: the first form for a given speed, the second for a given period or rotation rate.
  • • Centripetal force is the RESULTANT along the radius, never a fourth arrow. Nothing on a correct diagram points outward.
  • • Flat curve vmax⁡=μsgrv_{\max} = \sqrt{\mu_{s}gr}; frictionless banked curve tan⁡θ=v2rg\tan\theta = \frac{v^{2}}{rg} with N=mgcos⁡θN = \frac{mg}{\cos\theta}, LARGER than mgmg.
  • • Vertical circle: T+mg=mv2rT + mg = \frac{mv^{2}}{r} at the top, T−mg=mv2rT - mg = \frac{mv^{2}}{r} at the bottom, and vmin⁡=grv_{\min} = \sqrt{gr} when the rope goes slack.
  • • F=Gm1m2r2F = G\frac{m_{1}m_{2}}{r^{2}} with rr from CENTRE to centre; g=GMR2g = \frac{GM}{R^{2}} at the surface; v=GMrv = \sqrt{\frac{GM}{r}} and T2=4π2GMr3T^{2} = \frac{4\pi^{2}}{GM}r^{3} in orbit.
  • • Apparent weight N=m(g±v2r)N = m\left(g \pm \frac{v^{2}}{r}\right): weightlessness means N=0N = 0, never g=0g = 0.
  • • Banked curve below its design speed: friction points UP the slope, f=m(gsin⁡θ−v2rcos⁡θ)f = m\left(g\sin\theta - \frac{v^{2}}{r}\cos\theta\right); above it, DOWN.
  • • Spinning habitat: N=mω2rN = m\omega^{2}r, ω=g/R\omega = \sqrt{g/R} for 11 g on the rim, and the load on a deck is proportional to its distance from the axis.

Frequently asked questions

Is the centripetal force a real force in PHYS 101?

No, and saying so is worth marks. The real forces are the ones other objects exert: gravity, the normal force, tension, friction. Circular motion adds none of them. The phrase centripetal force is the name given to the resultant of those real forces, measured along the direction of the centre, and its size is the mass times the speed squared divided by the radius. Draw the real forces, point an axis at the centre, and set their sum equal to that quantity. If you add a separate arrow for it, you have counted one force twice.

When can I write that friction equals mu times the normal force?

Always for kinetic friction, once the object is actually sliding. For static friction, only at the single instant when the object is on the point of slipping, which the problem announces with words such as on the point of, about to move, minimum force or maximum speed. In every other case the object is at rest and static friction simply balances whatever is pushing along the surface, so you find it from the condition that the forces cancel, not from a formula.

Why are astronauts weightless if gravity is still there?

Because what your body feels is the floor pushing on you, not gravity itself. Four hundred kilometres up, the strength of gravity is still about eighty nine per cent of its value on the ground, and that is exactly what keeps the station on its circular path. The station, the astronaut and the sandwich are all falling toward the Earth with the same acceleration, so the floor never has to push on anyone. The normal force is zero, and that sensation is what we call weightlessness.

Do I need calculus for the circular motion chapter of PHYS 101?

No. PHYS 101 is the algebra based mechanics course at McGill, and every result in this chapter comes from Newton's second law, right angle trigonometry and ordinary algebra. Most solutions you will find online are written for a calculus based course and open by differentiating a position vector, which is not the method you are being examined on. If a solution starts with a derivative, it is not a PHYS 101 solution even when its final number happens to be correct.

Does a heavier car go off a curve before a lighter one?

No, and the reason is worth understanding. The heavier car needs a larger friction force to turn, because the force required grows with the mass. But it also presses harder on the road, so the largest friction available grows with the mass in exactly the same proportion. The two effects cancel and the mass disappears from the answer, leaving a maximum speed that depends only on the coefficient of friction, the radius of the curve and the strength of gravity.

How does artificial gravity work on a rotating space station?

The station spins, and the floor of its outer rim has to push everything resting on it toward the axis to keep it moving on a circle. That push is exactly what a bathroom scale reads, so it feels like weight. For a ring a couple of hundred metres across, one turn every thirty seconds or so gives the same push as gravity on Earth. A deck built closer to the axis turns at the same rate on a smaller circle, so its floor pushes less, in proportion to the distance: a deck at sixty per cent of the radius gives sixty per cent of the weight.

Practise it

Corrected exercises: Friction, circular motion and gravitation, PHYS 101 at McGill

A method is proved on a paper, not on a sheet. The set for the same chapter takes each of these traps into a problem, with the solution written out step by step.

  • 10 corrected exercises
  • 100 points
  • 150 minutes
Do the exercises
Something missing from this sheet? A method, a trap, an exercise to practise it, a mistake you spotted: tell me, I read every request.

Sending goes through your free space: that is how I can answer you and tell you when the exercise is added. An email is enough, no password. Create your space. Rather not create an account? Write to me directly.

What is it about?
I read every request myself, nobody else sees it. No need to write your name or your school.
When your request is dealt with, you hear about it by email and in your space.

By sending, you agree that I read your request to answer it. It is kept with your account, erased with it, and never published: privacy policy.

Previous sheet Newton's laws and free-body diagrams Next sheet Work, energy and power

© Ahmed Squalli Houssaini. Revision sheet published at www.letuteurscientifique.ca/en/fiches/phys101-friction-circular-gravitation. Free for personal and classroom use; republishing it elsewhere requires written permission (legal notice).

See also

Looking for a PHYS 101 tutor in Montreal?

Get in touch for a first session. On this chapter we start by drawing the real forces and pointing one axis at the centre of the circle, every single time.

Site by Studio Squalli